24th January.
THe respect universally felt for Mr. Cecil Holliday was the inducement to us to publish his valedic'ory letter of the 16th instant, but we entirely disseat from his conclusions. He represents the want of interes! in Municipal affairs <hown by the ratepayers of Shanghai as due to the fact that the meetings of the Counci approves the various acts of the Council," and "each Councillor himself should support or disapprove with the knowledge that his individual action and the reasons he has for it are known not only to his colleagues when they are shrouded in the traditional secrecy, but to every elector who takes a sufficient interest in Municipal polities to read the newspapers... Until the present system is done away with, and one where each Councillor has the privilege and responsibility of publicly stating and defending his own views is substituted, we can never hope for a really healthy Municipal life." Mr. Holliday winds up his letter by the statement that Shanghai has features' in its goverament only to be paralleled by Venice in the Middle Ages, which is such an amusing statement that it would be a crime to dissect it.
Mr. Holliday holds that the public would take more interest in Municipal affairs if the meetings of the Council were open tothe public. Why should he think so? All experience is against him. Meetings of Towa Councils and County Councils are open to. the public at home, and there 1s no more constantly recurring complaint in the Press than that the public everywhere allows itself to be served by inferior men and pays higher rates then are absolutely necessary because it, the indolent public, will not take a proper interest in its own self-government. If, then, we may argue from the analogy of the British public, throwing open the Council meetings here would not have the expected result, When there is no burning question before it, and while the Municipal chariot runs smoothly, the public, having asa rale its own personal affairs to look to, does not bother itself about its municipal affairs, which it elects and pays people to look after; and we feel fairly certain that the percentage of ratepayers who record their votes at the annual election of councillors here is as high as in England. As regards, then, dissipating the apathy of the ratepayers, there is, it seems to us, nothing to be gained by the proposed change. It must be remembered that the "traditional secrecy" of which Mr. Holliday complains is not such a very thick wall after all, and everybody who wants to can generally find a hole in it.
If there is little or nothing to be gained by the public from the proposed change, would it tend to improve the constitution of the Council? It would do just the opposite Tt is difficult enough now to secure every year nine candidates of sufficiently good standing, who will treat the Councillorship asa serious matter, and will work and not talk. Our 1 "Doge"—we are indebted to Mr. Holliare not open to the public. "The day for the idea—must be a man who ratepayers are entitled to know," he can talk a little so well as work says, "who supports and who dis- but beyond him, it is a great, thing
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.