Dr. Anderson's letter is worse than Mr. Foster's pamphlet. We called the latter mischievous cause, while reiterating the increas-Jed revenue from opium licences in Shanghai, it never said one word about the increased tax on those licences, and thereby, consciously or unconsciously, created a false and unfair impression. Dr. Ander-von goes even farther. Although by a quotation from our leading article he shows that he is not ignorant of the Treaty of May, 1911, he deliberately ignores that Treaty in his subsequent summery of events connected with opium and its influence in the present controversy. Does Dr. Anderson deny that the accumulated stocks in Shanghai came here under the authorization accorded by that Treaty 1 That they were marked for export te Chinn by the Indian Government according to the terms of that Treaty? And that in defiance of the Treaty China, refused to allow them to be sold after she had pocketed the duty that was paid upon them here? Dr. Anderson talks wildly about re deeming the millions of opium smokers, and Shanghai contaminating China for hundreds of miles. But on questions of justice and common honesty, his line of argument reveals a deliberate disregard of facts and a degree of manta! dis-tertian extraordinary even among those who, for the sake of eliminate ing one evil, have thought right to encourage China in the no less great one of trampling on her most solemn pledges.
Oct. 21.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.