The Archive · 1914

NATIONAL COMPANIES

To the Editor of the "No:

Sim,—I_ desire to congratulate you on your leading article "National Companies" which I have been an advocate of for ten years out of a residence of over nineteen years.

T would suggest that "A" and "B" Companies should be abolished and in their place English, Scotch and Irish companies be eubstituted, the Welsh members of this community to be embodied with their English confreres until such time as they have sufficient, numbers to form company of their own.

You hit the nail right on the head when you say: ''By the formation of national companies the door may be banged once and for all on the old invidious distinction between hongs and stores, That is a distinction which never ought to have been drawn in the case of men serving in the ranks and equally under orders, and the sooner it disappears the better, as it may easily do." Chie close distinction is carried to a ridiculous extent when one considers what the duties of the 8.V.C. are, i.e, the defence of the Settlement, and the sooner is realized the better, for sure-now is the time to make a encounters," and that after a fairly long run, you, Sir, thought fit to declare the correspondence on the subject closed. He now returns to the subject in the interes:

"economic and civilized progress." (2) In his recent letter ("The Burning of Louvain") that which seems to puzzle him, in the decorative and somewhat disconnected passage beginning "en pas sant," really should have been the positive conclusion of a letter Which confesses the ruin of the "international and economic edifice" and the failure of "civilized Are there any ideals of economic progress!" Progreas is a process in which neither starting-post or goal appear. Economic progress may mean simply the desire of every one to get on better, or the desire of everyone to get better off. Surely it just, such principles which inevitably lead to war, for war is only a striking example of the competitive principle. War seems almost to be a necessary conclusion of those doctrines of progress for which "G. N." 20 persistently pleads. The only preventive of war is some view of life which is not based upon principles of "economic progress." When "G. N." has sifted all that is left of "the ruins of the international and economic edifice," when he has learned to find his ideals in something more permanent than the shifting sands of a pleasing but misleading phraseology, perhaps he will be prepared to give more charitable consideration to the Christian ideal, Tam, ete, Shanghai, Oct. 21.

I would go #0 far as to suggest that all those members of the com-

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account