The Archive · 1903

The American Mail Papers

For Taz WEEK ENDING THE 17TH

the American mail,"n> recent, great is.

According to the just received by more importance in the United States than the announcement of President Roosevelt's decision in the case of Foreman Miller of the Government printing office. The President's decision, @ final one, was expressed as follows I am dealing purely with the relation of the Government to its employees. I must govern my action by the laws of the land, which I am sworn to administer, and which differentiate any case to which the Govern-mont of the United States is a party from all other cases whatsoever. These laws are enacted for the benefit of the whole people, and cannot and must, not be construe permitting discrimination against some of the people, I am President of all the people of the United States without regard to creed, colour, birthplace, occupation, or social con. dition. My aim is to do equal and exact justice as among them all. In the employment and dismissal of men in the Government service I can no more recognise the fact that a man does or does not belong to a union as being for oF against bim than T can recognise the fact that he is a Protestant or Catholic, a Jew or 2 Gentile, as being for or against him.

The day following this announcement, the American Federation of Labour, of which Samuel Gompers is the President, issued a long address to the organised labour of America, which contains this declaration regarding the "open shop" question The Hxecative Council of the American Federation of Labour takes this opportunity to say that the trades union movement stands for strictly union shops, experience having noyed that, where the "open shop" system 8 been tried reduction in wages and profits has ensued, wit disaster the industry practising that system, and therefore declares that the best interests of the labour movement call for the employment of union workers and discourage in every way, shape and form the deteriorating effects which follow the recognition of the "open shop."

As was to be expected, these divergent views have been provocative of a great, deal of discussion, some of which is of quite a lively character—the language used in some cases being more forcible than polite.

The New York "World" speaks most, enthusiastic terms of the President's decision, which it affirms is " creditable alike to his judgment and his courage." We take the following short comment from its It is thus settled, so far as a strong precedent can do so, that there is at least one employer—the Federal Government—to whom labour unions cannot dictate as to whom it shall employ or on, what, terms. The President remarks that "the laws of the land," which he is sworn to administer, ¢ifferentiate any case in which the Government of the United States isa Party. from all other cases whatsoever. lo. this is" perfectly true from the President's official standpoint, it may well be added that the fundamental assertion Of his ruling the right to employ and fo accept employment free from intimidation orvinterference by any authority un-Known to the laws of the land—in sort, freedom of contract—is as sound and as necessary to be upheld in its application to the Federal Government and its employees.

loyes and employees generally as to Yhe Brooklyn "Citizen," a Democratic organ, holds practically the same view, as is evidenced by the subjoined extract from its leading article President Roosevelt's decision in the Miller case is the only answer that he could possibly make to the impertinent demand of the American Federation of Labour. that Miller should be dismissed from the Government printing office because he is. a, nonunion man. We are sorry.that the President found it, necessary for political reasons to soften nis answer with apologies and flatteries to organised labour. The American people, however kindly disposed to the movement for amelioration and improvement of the masses, indignantly resent the attempt of the labour leaders to control economic conditions and to make the Government a party to their creed.

These two papers may be taken as giving a fair representation of how: the question viewed by the Democrats. The Republican Press, however, in its comments, is equally appreciative of the position taken by the President. The Kansas City " Journal," for instance, rays The President's attitude must commend itself to every fair-minded citizen, unionist or non-unionist. He will not refuse to receive the union labour leaders. He will treat them courteously. He will give them a respectful hearing. But he warns them defordhand that he has taken his stand on the constitution and laws of the country, and that no pressure they may employ will budge him. He is the President of the whole people. snd mot merely of trade unionists. The Government printing office is, there: fore, and is to be as long as Roosevelt is President, an "open shop." He has, of course, no desire to alienate the labour unions. They are a considerable factor in the politics of the country. But he does not propose to let considerations of self-interest swerve him a degree from what he regards as the of duty. His attitude is characteristic of the man—candid, fearless, and just.

The "Evening Bulletin" of Philadelphia, in its numerous references to the Manchurian question, continues to maintain that what-exer the outcome of the present trouble may be, the United States occupies the position of a disinterested witness. "China," it says, "has signed the treaty by which American commercial interests within her limits are safeguarded, and by which the two Manchurian ports are to be thrown open to our trade. It is not to be supposed without proof that the St. Petersburg Government will interfere to nullify this arrangement." One would suppose that the recent trend of events would be sufficient to indicate how far the good faith of Russia may be relied upon when it suits her purpose to-act contrary to the solemn engagements she has entered into. Perhaps it is a case of distance lends enchantment to the view.

The following paragraph is a part of its leading article on the subject For the next few days it is not improbable that all sorts of extravagant rumours respecting an anticipated clash between Russia and Japan may come from the Far Fast. A sample of this kind of exaggeration is afforded: by the statement that a fleet of ninety of the Czar's warships have been dispatched to the Corean port of Masampho, where a portion of the Japanese naval forces are stationed. Everybody who understands the salient features of the situation knows that Russia does not have anything like ninety vessels of war at her command in this region. Asa matter of fact, her squadrons there are easily equalled, if not actually outmatched, by the fleet of Japan, which is modern, formidable, and manned by officers and crews who gave the world a gli of their fighting ability by.the manner in which they promptly brought China to her knees, It may be true that' Russia entertains designs on Corea, and that Japan will fight before she permit "the Hermit Kingdom" to fall under Muscovite domination as Manchucia has done. It does not follow, however, that immediate war is inevitable, or that every movement of ships and soldiers portends ie. So long as Russia maintains her traditionally friendly attitude toward this country, thers is no reason why Americans should cancer, themselves whether she gets out of Manchuria or whether she finally comes to blows with the Japanese over the possession of Corea—a portion of the earth's surface in whose disposition we have no interest what: ever.

A fow weeks ago there appeared to be j & pretty general expectation that President Roosevelt would call Congress together in extra session next month." While the Pres ident is reported to be unchangeable in his determination to do so, many papers do not, see any necessary' for taking such action. To do so, it is asserted, would be "going to more trouble than the situation really warrants."

following short leader is taken from the "Evening Bulletin" of Philadelphia:

It has been commonly assumed that. his (the President's) call will be issued for the Sth of November. The regular session of Congress will begin on the 7th of December, or only twenty-eight days later. Yet thor condition of ational affairs which Tequires any action that cannot be just as well taken un and considered in December as in November. Extra sessions are only justified when a crisis or emergency is to he dealt' with, or when some question demanding immediate attention has sudden sprang up in the interval between regular sessions. Whatever legislation the country needs to-day or is likely to get can be enacted as effectively for all practical pur-pases after the 7th of December as after the Sth of November. Mr. Roosevelt ought to reconsider his determination. To get Con-ress together only a few weeks ahead of the regular time when the "long" session is to be held is not worth the vague sense of alarm or uneasiness which a proclam: for an extra one generally tends to produce in the country at large.

Under the heading of " Chamhorl: the United States," the " Chicago Chronicle,"

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account