The Archive · 1902

The Proposed Municipal Lottery

STRONG PROTEST BY THE REV. C. E. DARWENT

The Rev. C. E. Darwent preached on Sunday night in Union Church on the recent proposal of the Municipal Council to grant a monopoly to a Chinese to run a public lottery in the Settlement for the sum of $150,000 a year.

The preacher said the proposal was one of such vast importance to the whole moral, as well as the commercial life of Shanghai, that he made no apology for preaching about it. If preachers had nothing to say about a question like that they wore untrue to their mission. At the outset he said that he was a great admirer of our Council. He was not one of those who were always nagging: when ho remembered the diversity of the nationalities, laws, customs, jurisdictions, with which the Council had to wrestle, he was amazed at their success. It was, indeed, evident, he thought, from the terms of the announcement in the Councils minutes, that it would prefer not to be responsible for such a demoralising institution as a public lottery; they mooted it, it appeared, is an unavoidable necessity to avoid what they consider a worse evil: the clandestine circulation of unauthorised lottery tickets in the Settlement; that he understood to be the Council's position. He mentioned this because his general agreement with the Council added intensity to his grief that they even hinted at the probability of Shanghai being made a centre of corrupt tion to the whole Orient, He would ask, if it be right to have a lottery under the auspices of the Council, why farm it out to a Chinese? Why not run it as a dopartment of the Council itself? He supposed they would shrink from that; was it not] Ghinese for running it? In considering equally wrong to take money from a the subject, the preacher said, he woul first look at the attitude of great communities, nations, und cities to public lotteries secondly, he would show the innate evils of public lotteries; and thirdly, he would deal with the Council's plea thatit is better to havea Municipal lottery under control than the present unauthorised Chinese lottery.

They must quite'understand that public lotteries had been well and thoroughly tried inthe past history of the world. The evils resulting from them had been so conspicuous, obvious, notorious, as to lead to their utter condemnation. Therefore, if Shanghai permitted one to be established, it was taking 4 retrograde stop, fying righ history and experience. The Governments of France and England had both in the past raised money by lotteries; but he believed that the last great public lottery in France was as far. back as 1836; while the last Government lottery' in England was in 1826. They, had to be stopped on account of the mad excitement, dislocation of ordinary, steady, work they caused. These Governments were not animated by senti ment; they needed money badly enough! but out of respect to the moral life of the nations they had to cease raising money by public lottery. The whole life of the people as poisoned by the gambling fever; one only needs to read the records of the time to be convinced of that. What reason was there to expect that the opening of a effect in Shanghai than it had always had in other places in the past? It was an invariable rule that the less moral and Christian a community was the more it countenanced lotteries. Advancing moral life always led to the suppression of these excitements, to them the lowest form of gambling. A city that ran a lottery stamped itself as morally low down. Modern Governments suppressed them. The United States Government had refused to permit the national mails to be used for the conveyance of Louisiana lottery advertisements and tickets; that led to the suppression of the Louisiana lottery. Were they going to have in their midst an institution for which they would all be responsible, which would have its packets refused by the Western post-officer in Shanghai as too unclean, too immoral, to pass through the mails He could remember when England used to be flooded with circulars of the great Hamburg lottery, and what indignation was felt that the post should be prostituted to such uses, tempting even schoolboys to gamble. It was stopped—wouldany one have it revived -And/were they to begin in Shanghai what enlightened governments everywhere were suppressing? Could they imagine the Governments of England, the United States, or Germany instituting State lotteries' under even the greatest financial stress The fact was that the fever set up inthe community by public gambling was venomous, so demoralising, that even the "missing word" competition in a popular British weekly paper had assumed the dimensions of 'a national scandal, and had to be stopped. He would implore our Council not to hark back to methods of demonstrated corruption in their finances. Western Governments had to abandon lotteries not because they were swayed by high Christian principles, but because they suw they could not afford to demoratise their peoples. Was the Council prepared to sanetion this agency to demoralise Shanghai The fruits of lotteries have always been bad what reason had we to expect aught else here? He would beseech the Council to let this proposal drop.

The evils of public lotteries were peculiarly deplorable, He believed all. gambling was bad, un-Christian, and against public morals.' He would not enter at length now into the abstract question of gambling. He believed it was the most virulent form of the sin of covetousness: it created a rage for money, for money without working for it; it unsettled men from work; it kept men's minds ina fever of excitement. But whatever the abstract Feasons against gambling might be, the fact remained that it had always been classed with licentiousness and drunkenness. The "Rake's Progress" was always through a gambling den; it fact that all legislation was against it in Christian and even heathen countries; it was a fact that all wise legislators joined to discourage it; no one could deny those propositions matter what he thought of the cause of the evil of gambling. Were they gui deliberately "to sanction its offi introduction as an integral part of the life of Shanghai? This was all peculiarly true of public fu gambling, like this lottery. It wa ebrious to anyone who thought at all, the vice which receives the imprimatur and sanction of a governing body is ten tines as demoralising as when it has to skulk in the dark. He would ask the members of the Council to consider this. They would introduce far more ' undesirable features by sanctioning a lottery than they would suppress.

rst, there was no doubt the Municipal sanction gave a responsibility to a lottery that at present the evil does not possess. There were a great many, especially the boys and girls, who would argue that it Municipal lottery would have any other) cannot peso bad—as the Council permits No one could escape them. Hoe though; it. This reason alo revealed a greater evil than anything ed by the present unauthorised lotteries.

Secondly, a Municipal lottery would make the inducements to, and ample opportunities for, gambling, permanent, ever resent. He himself was of opinion that Shanghai afforded fewer opportunities for gambling than most pi The races ocourred only twice a year; at home you could gamble on them ull the year round nearly.

Thirdly, the Municipal lottery would -be the means of obtruding and forcing gambling on the attention of the public. It was absurd to suppose that this Chinese Tessar would not adopt every possible means of advertising it. "In fuet, if we took $150,000 per year from him, he would be entitled to push it by all means in his power. The Council would have no right to hinder him, In order to pay that $150,000, the Chinese lessor would have to make S410 every day, before he cleared anything for working ex: penses or for profit, and was Shanghai prepared to n from its residents, large young men of the Settlement Were we prepared to have our newspapers crowded with lottery advertisements? Were the members of the Council willing to have this thing forced on the notice of the young people of the Settlement? Did they st ing promitenco that would Municipal lottery, which intense fold all the evils of private What about the post? The lessor would be less generally were if he did not Hood our rabi With advertisements through the post—unless indeed the L. M. C. post refused to convey them. Had the Council thought how the whole commun Chinese, would be gamble, both by advertisements, placards ud post, if this thing were established Couldthatbeforthe goo of the Settlement Had the Council considered, in the fourth place, that the evil would not stop at Shang-There was no reason to doubt that that Chinese would not confine his attention to this Settlement. He would send his advertisements to distant plices.as Manila did, as Macao, he believed, devs. Was our Coun: cil prepared to make Shanghai a source of corruption to the whole East, and have Shanghai occupy the place morally that Manila used to occupy? He trusted that such degradation would never be thrust on Shanghai by its governing body.

He would lastly deal briefly with the argument the Council used in support of their proposed action—that as it is impossible to suppress the sale of lottery tickets in the Settlement the introduction of a well-administered lottery under Municipal control would remove many undesirable features." That sounded plausible but was fundamentally an unsound argument that could not stand a moment, He would like to ask had all been done that was possible to lottery tickets seemed to him that the Chin uppressiv in return for his SUSU Suppress the sale of lott s—prohanting that no police ably they could not: nothing would prevent, shroffs and_ others carrying them about Secretly. Granting that, he still maintained the evils of a public lottery would far outweigh all the of the present system. At present most people had to seek these lotteries. Cnder the proposed public lottery solicitations to take tickets Fould be openly thrust on people.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account