The Archive · 1908

The Criminal Appeal Act

Barely three months have elapsed since the new Criminal Appeal Act came into operation in England, bnt serious complaints are beard against the burden and cost of its working. Speaking at the recent Leeds Summer Assizes, Mr. Justice Bigham declared that the right now given to every prisoner to require the Court to hear an appeal had been shown by the working of the Act to be "unnecessary and even mischievous". Before the Act became law it was said thatthe number of appeals would be small and the cost of working would be small. Experience so far had shown that both forecasts were mistaken.

For there were then about fifty appeals waiting to be heard; in every twelve months some 10,000 prisoners were convicted; and if any proportion could be established between these two factors, his Lordship estimated that the new Court would cost at least £106,000 a year and that Parliawent, rer loth, would have to appoint additional judges to the King's Bench. These are serious statements coming from such a source, especially as Mr. Justice Bigham claims the best authority for what he says, apart from his personal experience. At the Court's first sit ting, it will be remembered, the Lord Chief Justice expressly pointed out that its duties were not to re-try a case but only to see whether the ver-diet ought to stand. Further checks were imposed by the judges' raling that 8 primd facie case must be made out for any appeal against avy verdict as being unreasonable or wrong in law; and by the provision of the Act that a frivolous appeal should be punishable by an increase of the original sentence. What now appears to have happened was feared by some opponents of the Act before it became law. In lodging an appeal the prisoner feels thet he has always sporting chance." He may be worsted—badly worsted, with " longer sentence than he began with; but he has the excitement of s new hearing, intervi his Iawyer and nds, better food and lodging while waiting the Court's decision, all combining to relieve the monotony of prison life. "It is clear that some greater stringency will have to, be imposed to save the Court from unnecessary labour. But (to adapt an old tag) no Act is suddenly most perfect; and the fact that. ander it some few prisoners have already strong argument that, with j cious patching, the Court of Criminal Appeal should yet develop into a useful and workable institution.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account