Several hours were occupied in ce: pleting the hearing of the charge against a runner attached to a likin station of the native city, of hoarding a boat within the boundaries' of the Settlement for the purpose of collecting likin.
Mr. Loftus E. P. Jones now appeared to proscente on behalf of the Municipal Council while Judge Lamme defended.
Tu a brief review of his evidence Mr. Jones said a wine merchant named Chang some time at the end of last year was expecting three boat loads of wine and. according to custom. he went to the likin office and arranged to pax $30 in full satisfaction of all likin claims in respect of the consignment. The boats arrived at separate times and the second. owing to a strong tide flowing, did not stop at the station as the others did. but right on to the Honzkew creek. where it was anchored. Thereupon the likin officials boarded the haaf. seized 16 inrof wine and took it back to their station. The $30 would have been paid after the val of the third bent. When the seizure took place the merchant likin station and after some di paid the amount arranged and it wa: promised that the wine should he retuned to him, bnt in consequence of correspon dence between the likin station and the wine guild there was delay in surrender:
the wine and Chang went to the police.
was through that action of his that the Council became aware of the illegal sciaure. The police made inquiries and the headman at the small likin station have the names of fortr men who had made the seizure. Prisoner was one of these and he was arrested. Action had been delayed with the object of securing the arrest of the other three men but that find not been accomplished. He (Mr. Tones) understood that it was not denied that the wine had been seized bnt that the Aefonce was that the seizure took place on the Chinese Bund and not at Hongkew. Hie should direct his evidence mainly to that. point in consequence.
The wine merchant Chang, in evidence. said he was in the habit of buying wine for all the merchants of Shanzhai. He anode the arrangement with the likin authorities to pay $30 for the dues three boatloads of wine. After the arrival of the first he went to the office and ex: plained that the other two had been delayed by great wind. At a little after ie o'clock on the fifth day of the first noon the second boat arrived at Shanghai and Iecause of the strong tide flowing did not stop at the likin station but went on to the Hongkew creek, where it anchored under the Seward Road bridge. One of the men aboard her was sent to the likin station to report her arrival. About four o'clock next day the runners arrived fo examine the cargo and the boatman told them it was the property of witness, who had already arranged for the likin, but they reinered the wine by force. On the following day witness went to the koongsoo. The headman was out, but witness saw the accountant, who said the likin people knew the wine belonged to him. He went againt to the koongsoo on the 9th of the Ist moon and was told his wine had been removed to the likin office. On the 10th, he went to the likin office only to be told the wine had been sent back to the koongsoo, He was able to identify his wine by two Chinese characters on it. Ho went to the koong-<oo again on the 18th and was told a letter had been written to the head likin office, but on going to the head office next the official said he had received two otters, one asking that he (Chane) should he heavily punished for evading likin pay-out, the other. that he "should" be leniently dealt with. On hearing this ho went to the Municipal police to recover his wine, which he valued at $50. He obtained the names of the four runners, inch ding prisoner, who seized the wine, the koongsoo.
"Cross-examined—He did not know ho was evading the likin tax; ho would have paid the $30 on the arrival of the third boat. He did not, report the matter to the police immediately because it was promised the wine should be returned to him. It was not till proceedings against him were threatened that he went to the police, Re-examincd—It was written plainly in the letter to the likin office from tha koongsoo that 16 jars of wine had been seized from the boat in the Hongkew creek.
Judge Lamme maintained that this letter should be produced, but the objection was overruled.
The boatman whose boat had been hired by Chang to bring down this second load of wine described his arrival at Shanghai, his passage by the likin station owing to the tide and his anchoring in the creek. About three o'clock next day, he said, three men came on board and one more gentlemanly in appearance looked on from the Seward Road bridge. They came to seize some of the wine; witness objected, but they took 16 jars, put it in a small bent and went away.
Cross-examined—Chang had told him to go to the Wharf on the Chinese Bund, but the tide carried him past.
'A second boatman, belonging to another boat, said he was moored alongside the last witness and saw the seizure as he had described it.
A native detective stated that on the 23rd of the first moon he visited the likin office and saw the jars of wine which had been seized. The officials said they received it from the koongcoo. Chang was with witness and they went on together to the koongsoo, where an official inside the counter gave them four names as of those who seized the wine. Witness paid two subsequent visits to the likin station and exentutally arrested prisoner, who, in the charge room at the police station admitted that he seized the wine, but, said it was done on the Chinese bund and not in the Hongkew creek.
Cross-examined—He only knew from hearsay that the seizure was at Hongkew.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.