Judgement on appeal from a decree of his Britannic Majesty's Supreme Court for China and Korea at Shanghai of January 10, 1907, it which the respondents, B Company, were plaintiffs and the appellants, Fong Tai and Company, were defendants was given on July 25 by a Jadical Committee of the Privy Council.
Mr. J. A. Hamilton, x. c., and the Hon. John Mansfield appeared for the appellants; Mr. Scratton, x.c., and F. D. Mackinnon for the respondents, The argoments were heard in May before s Board composed of Lord Macoaghten, Lord Atkinson, Sir Heary de Villiers, Sir Andrew Scoble, and Sir Arthur Wilson, when judgement was reserved.
Lord Macnaghten, in d ering (for Lord Atkinson) ' their Lordships' judgement last week, said the action out of which the appeal arose was an action in rem brought against the steamship Draco unier the provisions of section of the Admiralty Court Act, 1861, which applied to Shanghai ud Korea ing been arrested till after the institution of the suit, section 4 of the Act of 1861 did not apply. Section 5, however, conferred on the High Court of Admiralty jurisdiction "over any claim for necessaries supplied to any ship elsewhere than in the port to which the ship belongs, unless it be shown to the satisfaction of the Court that at the time of the institation of the cause any owner or part owner of the ship is domiciled in England or Wales." Seotion 10 gave the Court jurisdiction over, amongst other things, any claim of the master of any ship for wages earned on board of her, and for disbursements made on her account. By section 8 the Court was empowered to decide all questions arising between ce-owners or any of them touching the owner-possession, or employment, or the earnings of any ship regis at any port in England or Wales or any share thereof," and to "settle all accounts outstanding.... in relation thereto," and to "direct the said ship or any share thereof to be sold" and "make such order in the premises as to it shall seem fit." Section thirty-five provided that the jurisdiction conferred by the Act might be exercised either by proceedings in rem or by proceedings in personal. The expenditure in respect of which the plaintiffs claimed to recover might be divided into three beads, according as it took place in England, or at Shanghai, or at the intervening ports of call. The contentions pat forward at the trial on the part of the defendants were apparently (1) that the plaintiffs' claim was not in reality a claim for necessaries within the meaning section 5 of the Act of 1861, but merely a dain for the balance of an ordinary mercantile account; (2) that there being no maritime lien for necessaries, a suit in rem could not be maintained under that section, unless the time it was instituted the "res" proceeded against belonged to person or to persons personally liable to the plaintiffs in that suit as a debtor or debtors in the sum sought to be recovered; and (3) that, owing to the relations inter se of the several parties concerned in the transactions connected with the ship and to the notice and knowledge which the plaintiffs had of the defendants' equity able interest in or claim pon her before any of those disbursements were made,
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.