Edinburgh, Nov. 10.
The ballot under the Temperance Act has now gone far enough to show with certainty what the people of Scotland are thinking. The vast majority of the burghs have decided with the most unmistakable emphasis to have No-Change. The very few where No-Licence has won are just the kind where there was no particular need for reform. Four residential suburbs of Glasgow have decided for No-Licence, while the overwhelming bulk of the city, and particularly those wards where there is admittedly a drink problem, has pronounced for things to remain as they are. The same can be said of the almost negligible number of country towns which have voted for licence extinction. Altogether the result of the present campaign seems to stamp the Temperance Local Cption Act as a piece of quite valueless legislation.
In Glasgow, in the wards where there are most licences, the voting was uniformly for No-Change. The few wolds which declared for No-Licence were in the suburbs, where the private cellar is the important factor in the social habit. The total licences extinguished in the four outlying wards of a residential character do not equal one-half of the public-houses in the slummy Gorbal ward in the, centre of the city. In other words, the "select" wards have become more "respectable"; while the wards where reform was urgent, which were crowded and of low class, remain quite untouched. If this result means anything, it is that for the purpose of promoting temperance the Local Option scheme is absolutely valueless.
The battle was between the extrerists—No-Change and No-Licence, the only Options really voted upon. Another option is required under new legislation, which will give a proper reflexion of moderate opinion—and moderate opinion is on this question the large majority of the nation. Moderate opinion, supported by the whole press, demands a reform of our present public-house system. The Trade has promised to take an active part in this new policy, and the Trade must keep to its official promises as voiced in numerous election manifestoes. It is possible, therefore, that while this Local Option Act is defeated, a new moderate temperance scheme of reform will be inaugurated.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.