The Archive · 1921

The Tragedy of Oscar Wilde

A Mordaunt Study Oscan Wipe, ins Lire axp_ Coxres-By Frank Harris, Two (Published by the Author New York. $5).

In one of the lighter passages of this tragic book Mr. Harris goodhumouredly relates how he once overheard Wilde telling a friend in the next room that "Frank takes sincerity for style." The petulant fling was, of course, unjust, but it would be true to say that sincerity is the chief quality of Mr. Harris's style. He is not, on the whole, a refined artist in words; his attempt in this book to reproduce Wilde's conversation is, if Wilde talked as he wrote, a curious failure, and the subtler shades in the character, as in the style, of the man he is portraying escape him. He is kept from failure by his sincerity and his ruthlessness, which drive him to pierce through all masks to the real Wilde, so far as he can understand him, and to set down all his discoveries without flinching. We doubt, all the same, (says "The Times') if he has written what can be called the definitive life of the friend to whom he showed so pure a loyalty. It may or may not be the last life of Wilde that will be written, but it is nota final and satisfying estimate. It gives us, with limitations, Wilde the man, but it does not give us Wilde the thinker and artist. Only about a quarter of the work is allotted to the whole of Wilde's career before the downfall. Yet the bulk, though not the best, of his writing was done in those years, and that period was the period of his influence. It is, however, with

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account