March 21.
A sentence in Sir Henry Luc; "Sixty Years in the Wilderness runs thus:—'' A distinctive feature of the twentieth-century House of Commons is the disappearance of the orator." In his inimitable way the writer proceeds to tell how the change has come about; how Gladstone was the last survival of the oratorical giants, Disraeli never having been earnest enough, never "troubled by dominating conv'ction " enough to be really great how little by little oration has given place to talk, the classic quotation to homely wit, and the elaborate fication for repeating the bract ice. peroral in fully written out by The Badget in view of the Tram-some, to a pi mary of sober ways question must be expected to fact. Shanghai is not alone, there-give rise to no little discussion, fore, when she finds herself com-Even the circular issued on the eve pelled to lament tha loss of the of the Meeting, by which the Tram-fluent tongue, the ready wit, and ways Company. seeks to have "the the apt retort. Speakers there are last word is calculated to stir the in plenty who can give in length opposition " to a recapitulation of what they lack in depth, and who its whole case; for the question of unacquainted, perhaps, with Do-gauge is dismissed by the Company mosthenes, are still convinced, as as "unimportant," whereas a num-their gesticulatory efforts declare, ber of engineers would reckon the that his decision is right, and that "unimportant" difference in capital in oratory the first thing is Action cost per mile (including cost of cars the second, Action; and the third as well as of track material) at from likewise, Action. Where are we twenty to twenty-five per cent. to look for the cause of this decay Here, however, as in the case of dence? That it is widespread in the proposed pagoda, regarding which many are withholding jadge-the British realms is undoubted. What are the reasons? Orators ment until they hear the arguments, are made, not born. He who is the vote " is the thing." In the willing to chew pebbles enough, or matter of paving the Nanking Road suffer the smoke of the midnight: with wood it might well be sui that the submission of the as Bemosthenes did. But only if lamp, may become an orator even
motion without argument or his audiences permit.
They alone alone award the palm. Why. these days, do they refuse to do ssu? Tt may be that, satiated by, perhaps disgusted at, the efforts of an all-pervading mediocrity, they have~ lost the power of appreciating excellency. It may be that the Press: is to blame. What arguments, what facts, what illustrations can an orator now make use of which have not already been battered and: outworn by passage through an ever-clanging press? So it has: come to that whatever of true oratory has not been overwhelmed! by cacophony may have been swamped in a bog of printers' ink.
These considerations have beom suggested by the perusal of some old volumes of The North-China Herald"—those of the seventies. "There were giants in the earth in those days," oratorical giants fitted to be, in Shanghai, the contem-taries of Gladstone, Bright, israeli, and Lowe at home. The St. Andrew's Dinner gave them their opportunity. Not only were the Scotsmen themselves in full force, but their hospitality took care to include in the list of guests the hest spankers of other nationalities. So we find Mr. G. A. Lindsay, Dr, Henderson, Mr. Spence, Dean Butcher, Mr. (now Sir Char les) Dudgeon, Mr. Black, Dr. Jamieson representing the St. Patrick's Society, and several others, holding forth as proposers of toasts or in replying to them. We know nothing in present day Shanghai oratory to equal the efforts on there occasions, or even to approach them. The report as printed in "The North-China Herald's" pages fills nearly twenty columns, and both in form and substance is of an order highly creditable to a community which then numbered but some few hundreds of adults. Dr. Henderson was especially happy in after-dinner oratory. He had a firm foundation of culture to build upon, a breezy manner which wafted his audience willingly along, and a fund of humour always prepared to give from its natural spring that flavour of fun which post-prandial speaking demands. Then there was Dean Butcher, polished, perspicuous, popular We are still able to associate our local pulpits with eloquence, but Dean Butcher found frequent opportunit} for his talent outside the Cathedral and was ever ready with exactly the right word in the right place, always fall of that sympathy which is an Sesame" to the hearts of audiences. It is, perhaps, only fair to the present day to record the fact that the St. Andrew's dinners eloquence would be sufficient tolcan give the stimulus, as they|had a Johnson as reporter in the
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.