the defendants, amer laintif's st Mr. Jones moved: (1) Leave to
by claiming io the alternative "All accounts and fnqairies necessary to determine the amount due by defendante, or either of them to the plaintiff in the premises; (2) for an order direc the taking of such sccouots and the making of such inquiries are mentioned in the proposed postponing final jadge reanlt of such acconats an ingniries are Mr, Jones began to address the Court, bat, His Lordship ssid—I do not think that I want to hear yon, Mr. Jones. have considered the matter very care-folly. I will fret begin by shortly otating the position the action faction eventually came on for fore me, and I was able to arrive more oF less satisfactory solution of the difficulties which had been presented. I cannot feel that the parties would be, in the aggregate at all evente, better off T now diemisced thin ection and left into the plaintiff to bring x +nit asking for s different remedy in order that, the matters in di-pute might be determined. Rule 162 of our Rolex of Gourt, which governs the question of amendments, is this: "The Coart may Max 26 1910 of devermisiog. the real question made as may be necessary for the suc", al sach amendments to be
controversy between the parties." The principle of that rale is that, it possible, the, agtjon, should de-ly termine the real question in cent between the partis, and sitioogh might say that this action is improperly brought and that it might be pos for the parties to have all the matters in controversy settled in another action, it seems to me that that other would have to travel over almost the ground as has been taken in and it would be " waste of time also that on looking at my findings, that, in fect, I have ordered already that in the event of the parties not agreeing,*there shoald be an account or inguiry, for J use these words: "If the parties osnont agree, each must file an account and I will '4; point a referee, a8 this will probably involve heavy cost in sending bia to Sachien an agreement would be minently desirable"; aod then I go to speak of certain prices and to dicate the lines on which those prices way be determined.
That being the position that I have taken up in thie action, I wish to say that an order of that kind is not opposed to the principle-on which cases sre tried in Eogland, and Order 36, Rale 57 provides that, "it it spear to the court or a judge that the amount of damages sought to be recovered is substantially " matter of calculation... the court or '8 jadge may direct that the amount for which foal jadgement is to be entered shall be ascer by an officer of the court." That is the course which I desire to have tal is I want also just to advert to the question of the amendment, An amendment has now been ask; for by Mr. Jones which, if it had formed part of. the original petit would have enabled me to make this order without any difficulty. That which has gone before. The same points would. have been raised, perhaps not so many; bat substantially the case would have followed the course which it did follow. allowing this amendment now, because I think in the end it, will save expense to the parties and will determine the matters in controversy between them, I have looked carefully through the cases I can find no principle #0 baed and fast as would prevent me from granting this amend Therefore, propose to grant it, and in the terms in which Mr. Jones has drafted it.
They are practically the order which I should have made under Role 67, Order 36, bad I been oom) as a last resort to do that. Of course, the costs thrown away will have to be borne by the plaintiff. Ae regards the costs of the trial itself, it is little dificult for me to say
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.