The Archive · 1922

THE LAW'S DELAYS

To the Editor of the "Norrn-Cana Datty N Ws."

Sin,—I sympathize fully indeed with "Interested" whose article appears in your correspondence columns of last week under the caption of The Law's Delays."

take exception however to the statement which your correspondent makes that Shanghai Courts seem to be similarly placed as the Harbin Courts are, which have enough cases piled up to take at least three years to adjudicate. It is unfair to place all the Law Courts of Shanghai in the same I am not British and therefore have no axe to grind in this matter but I cannot but point out with pride indeed, that the British Courts in Shanghai, conspicuously among all Courts in the Far East, are administered in an excellent manner, for which at- least all British nationals should be proud.

It is true that there are cases pending in the U. S. Court for China awaiting trial, which will take many months finally to adjudicate and I agree with your correspondent that it is unfair to allow matters to continue in their ut condition. The situation is surely impossible and one might ay ridiculous and absurd. It is not only unfair to the lawyers, and litigants concerned but especially to the prisoners who are in the American gaol awaiting trial and who are unable to furnish the necessary bail bond or security so that they may be liberated meanwhile.

The fatest reliable information which has come to hand is to the effect. that Judge Lobingier will remain in Washington until the decision has been rendered respecting the charges brought against him by Mr. W. S. Fleming, and while we have been patiently awaiting some kind of a decision, promised several days ago, we now have it S. Circuit Cowt of Appeals of fornia hands down its decision with regard to the appeal which Mr. Fleming has taken from the U. S. Court for China, and this hearing has been set down for sometime in February, The reason given is that it is desired that any decision meanwhile should not prejudice either the American Judige or Mr, Fleming, for one of the charges which has been brought against Judge Lobingier is in connexion with Mr. Fleming's sentence for contempt of Court.

Now if this is the case, it seems that we cannot hope to expect any decision before the end of February after which either Judge Lobingier will return here and resume his duties or another Judge will be appointed in his place. This will mean that the U. S. Court for China will not re-convene again before some time during the end of March or April. Certainly such a state of affairs should not be allowed to exist and interested parties should take steps to bring to the attention of the proper authorities at Washington the necessity for appointing another Judge temporarily or, in any event, there is no reason why an Assistant Judge not be appointed permanent-

It is astonishing that the authorities at Washington, realizing what the state of affairs is here, should have allowed them to continue in this way.

I am, etc., Lawyer.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account