The Archive · 1904

RATHER MIXED

(ConTRIBUTED.)

21st March.

Wuen the German Ambassador at Washington suggested to Secretary Hay that it might be in the general interest to limit the territory of warlike operations between Russia and Japan, the American Secretary adopted the suggestion and neted upon it, To take the initiative was deferred to the United States because the proposal coming from that government was less, likely to be received with suspicions of ulterior designs. The Secretary deserves credit for so promptly recognising the foresight and wisdom of the Government of Germany, but to limit warlike operations and to keep China out of the war is one thing, while to preserve the integrity of China is another, The fact is, the war concerns, the integrity of China, for everyone knows that Manchuria is a part of the Chinese Empire an''that several of the leading Powers want Russia to get out of Manchuria, but Jupan is the only Power thus far that has undertaken to put Russia out.

It will be observed that Secretary Hay's note is addressed to neutral nations and invites them to join in representations to the belligerents made from a neutral st"ndpoint. Does it not then logically follow that it may not be the intention of such nations as are addressed to invite Russia out of Manchuria or to ask Inpan to refrain from the attempt to drive her out? Does. it meun that the neutralization of China refers to that part of the country south of Manchuria? It would appear to be so assumed, If Manchuria is not to serve as field for hostilities there will be no land to fight on except: Corea and even then the Russian base will rest in Manchuria.

If it be conceded that the neutralisation of China south of Manchuria be the abjret, qui a broad inquiry presen's usself Could not Russia claim tha' this was an ackuowledgment of her right to stay in Manchuria if not driven out by superior. force? And if the claim should be well founded, what would become of all the promise for the "open door" in that province? Are such questions reserved? They should be openly stated now.

The recent treaty ratified between China and the United States gives the latter country certain rights in Manchuria, but a proposition to neutralise China, to preserve its integrity, leaving out Manchuria, really seems that an acknowledgment of treaty rights there amounts to nothing, for rights cannot be obtained from China that are good in Russian territory.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account