Inn, was charged with committing a nuisance by permitting public gambling on his premises. He was defended by Mr. Holcomb.
Detective-Inspector McDowell deposed that on the 2nd instant, he was informed that the Police had received several complaints about gambling being carried on in the vicinity of Jessfield, and was instructed to investigate. At five o'clock on the same date, he called at the Jessfield Inn, accompanied by Detective Sergeant Burnside and Detective Kingston.
Mr, Holcomb interrupted, having arrived a little late, and pleaded that, under the regulations of that Court and the directions given by the U. S. Statutes, complaints and informations against American citizens had to be given with full particulars and sworn to at the Consular Court, and a copy thereof furnished to the accused. None of these things had been done.
His Honour said it had been the custom of that Court to regard the police charge sheets as sufficient. He (the Consul) had read over the charge to the accused immediarely after his arrest.
Mr, Holcomb protested that the authority and jurisdiction of the police extended only within the limits of the Municipality.
His Honour said the custom was for the police to take cognisance of public houses on the public roads, outside the municipal limits; and in this case, the arrest was made on his (the Consul's) warrant.
Mr. Holcomb submitted that no warrant should have issued until a sworn statement of the facts had been put in. The Court could commit error, just as other people could violate the law. He again cited the regulations, to show that the Court was bound to require an information sworn to and signed.
His Bihnour insisted that the charge sheet.
in usual form, complied with these regulations.
Mr. Holcomb refused to abandon the point, and added, further, that there was not a single line of American law which said an American citizen in China could be convicted of an offence for gambling. It was not an offence in Common Law. It was a statutory offence, and it was for the police to point out what statute the accused had violated, and what section of such statute. This Court was bound to demand that. By what section of what statute could the Court convict and punish his client? Until he knew this, hie client would refuse to plead.
Lits Honour—Then T will go on with the case without your pleading. The accused was brought in on a police charge of gambling in a public place, and thereby causing nuisance.
Mr. Holeomb submitted alternatively that if a nuisance was alleged, % was for the Court to order the suppression of that nuisance, but not to punish the accused uniers he was guilty of contempt in respect of such order by the Court.
Detective-Inspector McDowell, ordered to continue, deposed that there were three gambling machines in the bar, and several Sreigners playing at two of them, with twverfty-cent pieces. Mr. Childers was there, and conversed with witness and his companions. Witness tald him he would report the matter to his Consul. He did so, obtained a warrant. and read it to the accused. who said: "That's all right." Witness put in a magazine containing ilustrations (he said) of similar machines, which had been seized by thie police in America.
Cross-examined—The foreigners were not putting brass slugs in the slots, and the machines were not merely musical boxes. Witness instructed the other two detectives to try the machines, in order to make sure that they were gambling appliances, and in order to see if Mr. Childers would forbid their use. There were from twelve to fifteen people in the bar. It was just about the time of a Volunteer Parade out there, By the Court—This inn was resorted to by a good many people. Its general reputation was not good. There had been complaints about gambling, and witness had soon loose women there, Sergt. Burnside and Detective Kingston gave corroborative evidence, the former saying that he put about three dollars into the machines, and the latter about $1.60. First. witness explained how the machines worked. The person staking twenty cents took his chance of getting ten to one or twenty to one odds returned to him, or of losing his lake, There was no skill or science about Mr. Holoomb's cross-examination taking occasionally the nature of " badgering," His Honour advised the witnesses they need not answer. Mr. Holcomb made a remark to the effect that if the Court was going to suppress his rights of cross-examination, it was no use talking. The remark was not loudly made, but His Honour overheard part of it, and advised him to "be careful." Mr, Holcomb said "with all deference," that if he was not to be permitted to ask proper questions, he might as well "sit, quiet.""
At the end of the evidence, Mr, Holcomb raised another question, whether a conviction could be made where it was shown that "decoys" had been used to induce a person to commit an offence. On that point he said the law was so plain that a child could understand it. Repeating his former objections, he said that the U. S, Courts had not provided any law against gambling for their citizens resident in China, and the Court in this instance had therefore no jurisdiction, Gambling per so was not a nuisance; the method of conducting it might be. If this were a nuisance, it was a common law affair, and all the Court could do was to order the statement of it. Beyond that, the Court went beyond its power, and itself became a violator of the law. Until the law put it on the statute book and provided a penalty, gambling by Americans in China was legitimate business, however immoral it might be.
His Honour ruled that the complaint had eon put in in the regular way in which com plaints were put in in summary cases. With regard to Mr. Holoomb's last' objection, the police, in trying those machines, bad induced no one to commit an offence. They only proved that they were gambling machines. The Court was very anxious—the Consul personally was anxious—to lot it be known that no American in Shanghai or neighbourhood would be allowed to continue this gambling. It did not matter what anybody said to the contrary, they could not continue. This matter had been under his notice since last July, when a public complaint was made to him about this very inn, and about the California Hotel. He bad warned the owners then, and received promises that the gambling would be stopped. On his return he heard it was still going on, and wrote in. He had no wish to punish this particular defendant as severely as he would punish any one who might be convicted in the future. In this case the Court Marshal had been instructed to seize the machines and to hold them in custody, and to ship them on the defendant's order to any plume outside that jurisdiction. The defendant would also have to pay the expenses of the investigation and the Court costs—fixed in this case at $30 Mex. Another case of this Kind, on conviction, would be treated as a second offence.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.