The Archive · 1910

MUNICIPAL BUILDINGS

To the Editor of the "Nonru-Cuixa Day News."

Sir—A minute published in the last Municipal Gazette refers to " proposal invite Far-Hantetn architects to submit competitive designs for the rebuilding of Manicipal Offices. There is nothing original io the idea per se but judging. from one clause in whi committes of technical expert referred to, it is evident our city fathers have in this matter not received that professional guidance so essential to ultimate success, Since the word "expert" in this connexion can only refer to architects) by training and profession, the use of the words technical experts" in lieu of ' Architects " conveys the obvious inference that the awards will be made by technical experts other than Architects, The Council must not be misled into the fatal mistake of supposing that engineers—whether municipal, railroad, electrical, or mechanical—ean be classed as experts in purely building matters, nor are they better qualified to assess the merits or otherwise of Architectural Isnning and design than any other It should be obvious to the Council that reputable architects are likely to display " considerable amount of diffidence in hazarding their best efforts before any sach amateur tribunal as the wording of the minute suggests, A recent competition in Shanghai, conducted on similar lines to those by the Council, failed to attract all the Shangand most of the outport architects i speting, The award of the technical experts in this competition gave dissatisfaction to the competitors, as a design was selected which, under clause 17 of the conditions of competition, should have been disqualified. With regard to the success of that oom-petition, it would be interesting to read report by the Municipal Engineer, Architect, and Building Sarveyor as to the success or otherwise of the competition referred to, Tet, (Badge 1910. p 53) that we have We gather from the P. W. D. pay

Manicipal architect in receipt of;

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account