The Archive · 1910

Before the Full Court

APPEAL — Before Sir Haviuiaxo ye Savsmanez — Jadge, and F. 8. A. Bourse, Esq — 0.0, Assistant Jadge, REX DH. P. LRAY

This was an appeal from the Pro-social Court at Amoy.

Mr. A. 8. Oppe, on bebslf of the appellant, Harry Perey Leaver, applied for for a role nial for a writ of certiorari directed to B, G. Tours, Exq, formerly Judge of H.B M. Proviacial Court at Amoy, to remove into this Coort and to quash an order of conviction made on of about the 28th day of July, 1910, whereby the said Harry Percy Leaver was convicted of illegally arresting the persons of a Chinese and of a Japanese protected subject up n a jetty of the British Concessinn at Amoy without legal authorization and cot ry to the regelations of the said British Conopstin end wen eeoteaced to n Be of tty dollars or in detaalt to seven days' imprisonment, Oppe #aid that the grounds upon which thie applicati a set cut io the affids waiter in the service of the Imperial Maritime Customs of Obit od the time of the events hereiaalter stated stationed at Amoy.

2. The Castome House at Amoy is situate within the limits of the Brit Concession at Amoy. The har boat Amoy is within the limita of Chinese itary and Castoms officers exercise within the harbour the duties of police by virtue of Amoy Castoms Notification of 1904. A Customs jetty proj-cts from the limite of the British Concession beyond high water! mark into the harbour, 3. On Joly 22, 1910, " fight took place in the harbour of Amoy, close to on the water near the jetty and I was ordered by my superiors la the Customs service to arrest aod disarm one of the combatants who had fired " revolver and endangered the pablic peace, which I did, seizing the man in the water near the jetty, I afterwards handed over the arrested man to Customs officers who detained him la the Castoms House and later delivered him to the Chinese police in accordance with established procedure.

4. Ca July 27, 1910, B.C. Toors, Esq. H. B. M. Consul at Amoy, demanded so explanation as to sach arrest and detention from the Commissioner of Customs st Amoy, who referred hima to Peking.

5. On Jaly 27th, 1910, was served pra me at 5 pin. in th plaint of haviog illegally arrested two persons upon a jetty of the British Con-

673 cession at Amoy without legal authorization thereto and contrary to the regelations of the British Concession at Amoy. A trae copy of such summons is now prodaced by me, marked "A." T am informed and believe that there is no regulation of the British Concession at Amoy rendering the offence alleged in the eaid charge punishable by British or avy Court, or that the same is punishable as an offence by the laws of England.

6. The said summons was heard before B, G. Tours, Esq, H.B.M. Consal and Proviocial Judve at Amoy on the following day, Joly 28, at a.m, when the prosecution was condacted by the Registrar of the Court. I denied that bad effected the arrest within the limits of the concession or that the same was oolawfal and I applied for an adjouromont ix order to call witnesses, The Court refased each adjooroment and convicted me to a fine of fifty dollars or seven days imprisonment io default, 7. On Jaly 28 I paid the ssid five and applied verbally for leave to On Joly 29 I letter from the Registrar of the Court setting oat the conditions on which eave to appeal is granted, A tree copy of auch letter is now prodaced by me, marked 8. On receipt of and in accordance

verbally to B.G, Tours, fo with the terms of euch letter ppt copy of the jadgement of the Onart, a was informed that as the case was not a criminal case there was no judgement.

9. Ao Jaly 30, I filed with the Court a written application to appeal, true copy whereof is now prodaced by b|me and marked ~+0."

On the 2od Angast I received from the registrar of the Court n letter refusing leave to appeal. A true copy of the said letter now prodaced by me and marked 10. T advised and belies the Provincial Court at Amoy had no jarisdiotion to convict, for the following (i) That the complaint discloses no offence at law or against the regelations of the British Concession at Amoy.

Gil) That if it discloses an offence Amoy, the jurisdiction acquired by the Provincial Courts under euch regelations is limited to offences committed withia the limits of the British Concession and that such alleged illegal arrear was not committed within the ite of the (iii) That in any event such alleged illegal arrest was not illegal, was lawful and that I claim of right before the Ooart at Amoy and that such claim of right ousted the jurisdiction of the Court to convict.

11. I am farther advised and believe that the refusal of the Court to grant a postponement to enable me to call witnesses was contrary to the dae administration of justice.

12. The document now produced to me and marked "E" is to the best of my knowledge and belief a trae copy of the Jadge's notes of the said case,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account