The Archive · 1922

The Amoy Dispute

A correspondent to-day offers an interesting theory to explain the bitterness of the Amoy boycott, which indicates that Messrs. Butterfield & Swire are being made to suf-for for the sake of public, or rather student, indignation with the British Consulate over the walls and gates erected at each end of the Concession for its protection. On the face of it, the one agitation has about as much justice as the other. The fact that a portion of the sea-front opposite the Concession was reclaimed by Chinese labour does not affect the case, inasmuch as the Concesson had sheng ko rights over it and its filling. That there was jan agreement concerning the filled-in portion also does not appear tei disentitle the residents of the Concession from protecting their property. Nor, again, could the closing Jof the gates at either end in times lof trouble be fairly considered an interference with public rights of way, which, in revolutions, are superseded by the needs of public safety. If the behaviour of Chinese lin Shanghai is any criterion, those in Amoy would be remarkably glad of such gates and remarkably sorry to see them go. Speaking generaily, it is not the habit of His Majesty's Consuls in China to 29 about the place riding roughshod over Chinese rights. But these are days when any superheated demo crat can rouse a whole town in defiance of fact, justice and common sense—to the secret but inert annoyance of his elders; and when, as our contributor to-day says, " officials do not rule, they correspond."

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account