Tue letter from Mr. H. D. Hutchison which we publish this morning throws a little more light on the circumstances of his resignation of his seat on the Municipal Council. If we read his communication aright, the main point at issue between him and his former colleagues is the condact in detail of Municipal affairs. At the time of the trouble among a section of the Sikh police that led to proceedings in Court it was decided to have an investigation of the causes of disaffection in the Police Force, and we learn from Mr. Hutchison's letter that "a rough draft of a proposed reference to the officer who would be appointed to conduct the inquiry was circulated" among members of the Council. Mr. Hatchison appended to this draft "a considerable number of questions," which, we are led to infer, reproduced various allegations and reports," which being the subject of general comment, he felt, ought to be disposed of in the official inquiry. Apparently the pro terms of reference never came before the Council in full meeting and the subject would not seem to have bein discussed again until December 19, when the Indian Officer appointed to conduct the investigation into the Sikh question met the Watch Committee. Mr. Hutchison's annotations to the draft terms of reference appear to have been read to this Committee meeting, at which he was not present, and in the form presented, we have to conclude, they were taken to be his own definite strictures. As such they were presumably challenged in the proper quarter. It is to the Minutes of this Committee meeting read and confirmed, as the " Municipal Gazette" informs us, at the Council meeting on December 21, that Mr. Hutchison has taken exception. He regards the wording of the Minutes us tantamount to censure on action taken by him in his capacity as a Councillor and has accordingly resigned his seat. The Council now states that ie its view the Minutes indicate no censure, while none was suggested by the Watch Committee. It is at least a satis-
749 factory assurance that no censure is otherwise than instinctively on was intended, and general regret the side of constituted authority. will be felt that Minutes should Where criticism has, it has be so drafted and by the! been almost. always a matter of Council 2s to lead anyone to read departmental detail, and if such into them a possible censure. detail comes to have peculiarly We confess to considerable diffid-wide scope, the fault does not ence in commenting upon the lie with the community. It internal organization of a body realizes the difficulties of the which necessarily reveals so little Council's position and thoroughly of its inner working as the Muni appreciates the public spirit that cipal Council. But the resignation prompts Councillors to give their of a Councillor on a question of time and their services to the com-principle is too important a matter monwoslth. Moreover, it is satis-in its ing on the conduct of fied that, when things ate left to Municipal affairs to pass unnoticed. its nine' representatives, there is To the public it will seem strange that, when the draft terms of every chance of sbeir being very reference for the Sikh inquiry had' partments, however, imply that the well managed," Wateriight'com-been annotated to the extent of "a intellect of nine men is not being considerable number of questions," used, though they stand to share embodying " various allegations and responsibility for errors of jadge-reports," they should never have been ment arising from precipitate submitted to the Council as a whole. action. Mr. Hutchison's resigna-'The separate Committees, it would tion comes an inopportune at be imagined, exist for the facilitamoment, li aport be true that tion of work and not to perform difficulty is likely to be experienced the functions of the Council in fall in filling vacancies on the Council meeting assembled. If certain next year. The community can ill draft terms of reference for a police spare men who are not only inquiry are considered inadequate thoroughly keen upon Council by one or more Councillors, it would work, but. also devote themselves seem a normal.course to pursue to conscientiously to the study of give the whole Council an opport-public affairs in general. It should unity of evolving terms of reference not be difficult, however, to ro-that would meet with its unanimous medy a state of things that cannot approval.
We can well understand] be satisfactory to any party. In that the Council did not intend to endorse pungently worded Minutes censuring or even criticizing one of its members in a matter in which he bad not been given an opportunity to explain his position. Nor presumably did it solemnly record its wish on a recent occasion that a solecism in diplomatic correspondence should be perpetrated, which could only have the effect of earning for Shanghai a reputation for churlishness or puerility. Small points such as these esca the notice of busy men, and the community has no wish to see them saddled with mistakes for which they bear only technical responsibility.
In the present instance th terpretation placed upon the Minutes in question by Mr. H. D, Hutchison is disputed by the Council, and unless they are published in fall, it will be impossible to decide on which side right inclines in regard to this specific point. The principle, however, remains, and we recently had occasion to characterized it, for want of a better phrase, as government by watertight compartments. It is difficult to find justification for such a system, unless, indeed, it worked successfully. On the contrary, however, it appears to be consistently unfortunate. It is a mistake to suppose that the community most communities the government is conducted on regular stereotyped lines, set forth in standing orders. Ifthe Manicipal Standing Orders do not provide for the unchallenged able paramountcy of the Council in fall meeting assembled, a clause to this effect might be inserted.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.