The Archive · 1905

His Lordship agreed with Mr. Phi

there, Mr. Phillips submitted that if the dants were liable for the acts of the compradore they were also liable for the acts of the shroff appointed by the compradore. It seemed to him that it was impossible to distinguish between the two, His Lordship considered they were very different, It came'to the question of delegation. Either the shroff was the bank's agent for that purpose or not. His Lordship did not think he as the agent. Ho was a subordinate servant of the compradore who allowed him to do that. In his Lordship's opinion the shroff was not authorised to uso the chop by the bank, Mr. Phillips said that he was going to refer to one or two cases and text books hich this topic was alluded to.

jonahly masters were linble for acts of their servants up to a certain point, Counsel referred his Lordship to Story on Agency (1874, 8th Ed. p. 542, $541), on the liability of principals to third per sons. Also to §452 of the same on the liability of principals to third orsons in civil suits, Counsel also re-forred to p.485, $454, on the liability of rineip: ls for the acts of persons employed by their agents. Ho then ferred to the case of McGowan, Ld., v. Dyer (8 Queen's Bench, Vourt of App. Law Reports p. 145).

His Lordship thought this case not apply. The decision, if applicable was a very strong one against Counsel Mr. Phillips then referred to Roscoc's isi Prius Rules, (17th Ed., p. 656), which ated that generally fraud of the agent in the course of his principal's business was fraud of the principal. Counsel said that Me. Platt had referred his Lordship to numerous cases, one of which was the Bank of Ireland 'y. Evan's Trustees. His Lordship had referred to the case of Reuben v. the Great Fingal Consolidated. It seemed to Counsel that these oases did not apply to the case now before the Court. These dealt with negligence simpli acts of the persons who committed th frauds were outside the scope of their employment, Negligence was not the proximate cause of the low to the aggrieved person. Counsel referred his Lordship to Mr. Baron Parkes' statement when giving the opinion of the judges on the Bank of Ireland case to the Lords. In the case of Reuben, etc., the Master of the Rolls stated rule governing the responsibility of a master for his servant (2 King's Bench Pp. 727), that the act must be one of the class of acts the servant was put thers to do. Counsel also quoted the judgments of Lord Justice Sterling and Lord Justice Matthew on the same case. Counsel contended that in the Bank of Ireland case mere negligence did not make defendants liable. There must have been a holding-out. He submitted that class of case did not in any way apply to the one before the Court. Counsel then referred to Barwick v. The English Joint Stock Bank (Law Reports, 2 Exchequer, 1867, p. 259), which he sub-mityed was still the leading case on the subject, having been referred to in recent years by the Master of the Rolls. Than there was the case of Mackay v. the Commercial Bank of New Brunswick (Law Reports, 5 Privy Council Appeals).

At this stage the Court adjourned until 2.30. immediately on the resumption, Mr. Phillips said he would to have on notes, although camera little out of the proper place, the s*atement that. Lordat the defendants mere teed aguinst any defalcation by the compradore. All had to sxy in regard to the point was that suitable person way selected and appointed to this position of compradore under substantial guarantees, His Lordship said it might be added hat the possibility was couemplated of the compradore compromi ing the bank.

Mr. Phillips plied that that was the jeason for obtai: the guarantee. "With egard to the linby ity of a priveigal or master for the frame of his ant, whi acting within the scope of his employment, Counsel cited the Chinvse case Swire Francis (L. R. 3 Ap. cases, p. 106), and urged that it strongly supported his con-mention that, as far as the compradore was concerned, the defendants were liable for any fraud committed by im or which came within his purview.

His Lord: had not agreed with Couasel in his coutention with regard to the lability master for the acts of the servant within he scope of his authority and had said ti this might be a cue of delegation of authority.

His Lordship avid he had not put his el jection that way. He had said that he di id not agree with Counsel in naswming that the bank wns liable for the act of the shroff, the bank had never authori-ed the shroff.

Mr. Phillips replied that his Lordship had said thi might be a case of delegation of authority from the compradore which ought to be considered, and that being 80 he (Counsel) would refer to the case already mentioned by Me. Platt, that of De Busch Alt (8 Chancery p. 310). Thesiger, he contended, in The his judgment in this cave, strongly sui ced the stator it ree a from liability of the or tort of his xtended not only t" thi oF wrongs committed by the ut but also to other persons who might be employed by In this case, Counsel urged, the. exigencies of business did occasion the appointment of some person under the compradore for the doing of certain things, viz, the affixing of the chop to documents in the compradore's department. In an institution like bank was impossible for one man or two men todo all the work, it wis essential that

certain acts. The shroff in th's case was in ubordinares should be oppo nted to do precisely the same position as the accountant or cashier in any of the large f reign banks of Shanshai. It therefore seemed clear to Counsel that the employers, the defendants, were liable for such acts as were committed by the shroff within the scope of his employment, The defendants: had held out the camp-adore s having authority to contract loans and the comis chop t" the shir He sub-itted that the procedure was in acrordnew with the usual practice both ut f eigners and Chinese and that the defendants were therefore linble.

There was one other point Counsel had omitted to deal with. Mr. Platt has s+g-gested that the whole of these desiings by the native banks were with the shroff and without the knowledge of the compradore. Counsel submitted that the compradore must have been cognisant of what went on; the evidence showed that the negotiations took place in his office and in hi presence. It was true that is Lordship had come to the conclusion, on the whole vf the evidence, thet the pai shroff did not actually speak directly to the compradore about these louus, but they were negotiated with the shroff in his presence. The negotiations were carried on daily, ani Counsel submitted that the conclusion must be formed that the compradore kn' of them. The business wax not done secretly in any way. In this connection ere was the evidence, not altogether thout point, that the compradore was Cantonete and did not thoroughly under. stand the dialect spoken at Hankow.

Tu conclusion Mr. Phillips ran' "gain briefly over his points. On the question

defendants he addressed a few words whether the plaitifs did give credit to his Lordship xs a judge of fact, Hin Lordip had appeared to be impressed by the fact that the plaintiffs or their pres tives probably had knowledge of istence of the compradore's private coal business, and it was not unlikely that they should have made these advances in respect of the business, But there was no evidence that money was required fur the coal business. No question was asked of the plaintiff' witnesses in respect of that point. advances to the compradore directly.

The plaints donted that they made any compradore himself denied that the advances were made w him fur the coal Mr. Platt interposed the remark that there was certain lence of the shroff.

Mr. Phillips said he was coming to that. The only evidence at all on the point was that which his Lord<hip had described as untrustworthy, viz., that of the shroff, who said that the money was wanted for the coal business.

His Lordship remarked that the shroffs atement was that he told the plaintiffs that the money was required for the coal business, and he (his Lordship) had com. mented that he should be very reluctant to decide the issue on that evidence alone.

one point i had been willing to believe, that was statement that the other shroffs knew of the existence of business. In regard to come to the cmclision simply that the shroff was telling a lie, but he did say it would be unsatisfactory to decide Like this on evidence of a man la the position of the shroff.

Mr. Phillips observed on that, that leaving out the evidence of the shraf, a conclusion unfavourable to the plainti on the point must rest on surmise only, On the question of " holding out," Counsel understood rdship to agree that the defendants did hold sed the compradore to have authority to contract tons on their behalf ant the evidence was indeed overwhelming on the point.. In regard to the use ut the chop, Counsel relied strongly on the fact that the chop bore in Chinese the name of the defendant bank and the affixing of: that chop to a document was equivalent for the Chinese to the signature of the-bank. Again the representatives of two. other banks were called, and they explained

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account