The Archive · 1904

The Tension Between Great Britain and Russia

29th July.

WHATEVER may be the ultimate outcome of the present belligerent attitude towards neutral commerce, or of the excitement which certainly seems to prevail at home with regard to the recent seizures, it must not be supposed for a moment that war is the only logical outcome of a failure to obtain immediate reparation.

It is almost axiomatic that in modern times here' are two necessary ingredients, both of which must be found ce-existing ina greater or less degree, in order to form the motive power required to force a civilised nation into war. The first is the existence of a casus belli and the second ig the existence of a martial spirit in the country. If one of these ingredients is lacking in force the other must be proportionally great, but both must be ce-existing, and in the case' of the latter the necessity for its being a strong or apathetic spirit will depend upon whether a nation is more or less democratic in its methods and However many exceptions there may be to'this proposition, it is certain that, as the outcome of the modern reluctance to plunge into war unnecessarily, many expedients have been devised for btinging'pres-site to bear'on another nation, short of actual hostilities. These expe-! clients are dealt with' by writers on International Law under the heading of "Steps short of War or Pre-belligerent Acts," and may be shortly enumerated under the headings of "Rétoisions, Reprisals, Sequestration of, Property, and Pacific Blockade.

true that,'thésé' methods'are in practice generally only employed.by a stronger nation' against a weaker, and it-is open to a nation' subject to them to trest them as acts of war.

'The present somewhat indisctiminite action of" Russian commanders, However, in - their Siertitichs on neutral commerce, and their' appar-inability: to conform to the ordinary ent-ignorance.or their reluctance or

recognised procedure, ' bids" fair" to raise one very important question and one in which we think the solution is tobe found for the present difficulty.

All readers of International Law know that amongst the mass of writing that has been done on the subject there is to be found much discussion and learning on the so-called "Right of Convoy." This is a claim which has frequently been. put forward by Continental Powers and may be shortly defined as "The Right of a Neutral to claim exemption' from visit and search for' those of its mercbantmen as are under the immediate convoy of its ships of war." In other words the claim that a Government ship is to be allowed to go bail for neutral ships and as it were, guarantee that those ships are not engaged, whilst under such escort, in any acts, e.g., carrying contraband, sailing for a blockaded port, engaging in unneutral service, which would entitle: the belligerent to search them. Such tight has always been withstood successfully by England, for: the reason that experience has taught us that such convoying does not in fact afford the proposed security. The int has been decided as far as england is concerned in the case of the Maria, and the decision of Lord Stowell (then Sir William Scott) that case has always beer quoted: as good law by all the eminent English writers on the subject. The net result of that decision is that apart from special treaty: stipulation, England declines to recognise any such right as that contended for by continental authorities.

What could be simpler then, than for England, in the present case' to notify Russia that in consequence of

with proper' respect to the rights of her' total inability to ire Syed war isvahe will be obliged For the ud without prejudics to any future action in the matter, to insist on a right which in her opinion is: not, under ordinary circumstances, properly claimable by a neutral. would'be'a comparatively easy matter for our ships of'war'to patrol those "wa'ers* which are liable to Russian depredations and stich' a step would be far preferable ' to raneing the risk of a grave' European war. We have very little doubt that''stich a: course-could -and would' be adopted long before it was thought to plunge the country into war on account of incidents similar to those which have been so frequent of late, The answer to the question whether or no such a course will be adopted will depend on the attitude of the Russian Government and particularly the attitude of the Russian Prize Courts. If the former fails to make ample reparation for ships destroyed without being brought in for adjudication, or the latter fails to decide cases in accordance with established precedents, some such steps as these will; have to be taken as an alternative to war,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account