The Archive · 1923

A Lucky Murderer

By an extraordinary piece of luck, Rene Jean, the butcher who, as I related in' my last letter, divided his time between honest trading and conducting the affairs of a sang of murderous ruffians, has escap tha extreme penalty. The jury, after two hours' deliberation, returned to court with a verdict per which found extenuating circum-starniees for eight of the prisoners, including Rene Jean. His intimate friend, Tissier, was found guilty without any mitigation, and the others were acquitted. This finding was so unexpected that one of the defending counsel asked the judge if he could not invite the jury to retire and make-sure that there had not been some mistake. The judge did not sea his way to de this, his view being that a ver-diet once given in open court must stand, but after he and his assessors had retired to consider their judgment, it became evident that there was considerable foundation for the theory of a mistake. Jury-men, counsel and public formed an excited group in the centre of the court, several juryman protesting that the finding of extenuating circumstances for Rene Jean was intended to apply to only one of the murders and that the intention of the jury had been to send both him and Tissier to the scaffold.

The jury did not understand the effect of the questions they were required to answer, and, as they were not allowed to deliver their finding in their own way, the result was let off the principal offender. As Rene Jean had turned informer against his accomplices, the _jury-

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account