The Archive · 1923

Damaged Hogsheads In the U.S. Court for China on

Monday, his Honour Judge Lobinglor heard an action by the Universal Leaf Tobacco Ca,, Me. against the Barber Steamship Lines, Inc. for G.$45,016 legs Tls. 12,876, for damages incurred through alleged negligence in the handling of a cargo of 249 hog-shoads of tobacco, consigned to Shanghai. The claim states that the cargo was shipped in good condition in March, 1920, on board the str. William Henry Webb. Of the 249 hogsheads, 71 were broken or damaged to such an extent that their contents were intermingled. Defendants, in their answer, allege that damage was entirely due to plaintiffs' negligence in not providing sufficiently strong packages, that under the terms of the contract it was agreed that the value of the tobacco did not exceed $500 per freight ton, and that the defendants were not responsible for any further loss incurred by plaintiffs.

Mr. F. J. Schuh] appeared for plaintiffs and Mr. J. B. Davies for defendants.

CARRIED ASHORE IN SHEETS, Mr. G. D. Happer, manager of plaintiff concern, gave evidence that 10,000 Ib, of tobacco was landed practically in bulk in Shanghai. The hogsheads had almost entirely disappeared. The tobacco was carried ashore in sheets and dumped in the godown.

Cross-examined by Mr. Davies, witness stated that some of the tobacco was packed in Richmond, Ya., Oxford, N.C., and Henderson, N.C. It was shipped in February, 1920, and reached Shanghai in July of that year. Witness did not see how the hogsheads were stored in the ship. Witness received no notice of short-landed cargo. Re-dried tobacco of this description in the Shanghai climate would be in a bad condition after 48 hours exposure.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account