The Archive · 1923

A Witness of the Discharge

Mr. G. N. Marshall, managing director of G. N. Marshall & Ca., stated that he examined the hogsheads at the China Merchants' Eastern Wharf. The cargo was all over the bottom of the pontoon. Tarpaulins were spread over it. The tobacco was removed in baskets and by bamboo coolies into the godown. The remains of the hogsheads showed signs of having been pierced by sharp objects. The part of the consignment landed in bulk, was stacked in heaps over the floor of the godown.

Continuing, witness said that he and Capt. Angus from the bridge deck watched the landing of seven or eight hogsheads. As they were dragged across the floor of the hold they struck against the ends of reinforcing steel bars. The discharging was very carelessly done. Not only was it carelessly done, but it was done without any regard to the nature of the cargo. Had it had normal handling it could have been landed in sound condition.

Mr. Davies (cross-examining) suggested that it was possible in an emergency to get cargo through the Customs in eight hours.

Witness—If the Commissioner of Customs were in a good frame of mind. It would be necessary to see him first.

Capt. Percy Y. Angus, marine surveyor, said the pontoon, bridgeways and wharf were littered with tobacco leaf after the cargo had been unloaded.

The case was adjourned.

Marine Surveyors and the Packing of the Cargo: Unqualified Condemnation The hearing resumed on was Tuesday.

Mr. C. Reeves, cargo surveyor, of Messrs. Eisler, Reeves & Murphy, examined by Mr. Davies, stated that he had known from the wharf report, a most reliable document, that 72 hogsheads of plaintiffs' "tobacco were landed in a damaged condition. He did not investigate the marks or numbers of these hogsheads. Sweepings, that was to say loose tobacco in the hold of the William Henry Webb, were delivered in bulk atter the cargo had been discharged. There were possibly 2,000 Ib, of sweepings. A wharf report was the most accurate, scrutiny of cargo obtainable.

Witness did not recall who approached him on the wharf with regard to the Universa) Tobaceg Co.'s cargo. Their hogsheads were frail and insufficient, not capable of Standing the ordinary vicissitudes of modern ocean transportation. For that reason the ship was not responsible. It was the ship's business to see that all possible care was taken of such cargo, but in this instance, owing to the frailty of that cargo, absolutely no responsibility could rest with the ship. Witness believed that a recommendation for sale of the cargo by auction was made on the certificate of condition. And he was fully convinced that that recommendation was made ait the suggestion of the consignees. No fault could be found in the stowing or handling of the cargo in the ship.

In answer to the Judge, witness said that practically no other cargo save tobacco was packed in these hogsheads. He considered them quite inadequate for ocean shipment.

His Honour—Then the whole of the tobacco trade does not know how to ship its products?—They certainly.do not know how to pack for ocean transportation.

Replying to another question, witness told his Honour that consignees of tobacco very seldom. put in claims against shippers.

Cross-examined by Mr, Schuhl, witness said he had not heard ofa strike in New York when the William Henry Webb was loading there. Sweepings of tobacco were removed from her hold in sheets. Most of the breakage occurred in landing portions of the cargo which had already been lightered. Wit-ress did not agree that some hogsheads were completely ruined, al though it was true that some of the steel bars were sticking through them.

STANDARDIZATION REQUIRED, Captain S. Bayes-Davy, marine and cargo surveyor, of Messrs. Paulsen & Bayes-Davy, was then called. He stated that he held an extra-master's certificate. He had never known tobacco cargoes from any ship to be landed' undamaged in Shanghai. Witness practically introduced the present system of tallying and checking cargo. Since 1907 he had examined most of the

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account