The Archive · 1904

Drastic Changes

Whether the new scheme prove practicable or not, however, there cannot be the smallest doubt of the absolute failure of the Brodrick reforms. The three years? service system was based on the anticipation that 75 per cent of the men would be willing to extend their service in consequence of the inducements held out to them; as a matter of fact not 12 por cent remain in the army, and the proportion is constantly dwindling even from this low figure. The consequence is that whereas some 24,000 men are required for redrafts to India, not a tenth of this number are available. Mr. Forster's scheme, broadly, is to abolish the army corps and the "linked battalion" system, and to divide the the whole army into two parts, a "General Service Army" to serve at home or abroad, and Homo Service Army" to serve at home in peace, but wherever it is required in war. The General Service Army is to be enlisted for nine years, and the Home Service Army for two years, thereafter going into the Reserves; and Mr. Forster calculates that all time-expired men of the General Service Army will be able if they want it to obtain employment in training recruits. Fourteen battalions are to be abolished, and the remaining battalions of the Regular Army are to be reduced to 500 each,—400 Home Service and 100 General Service. Thoro is to be a small Striking Force of 15,000 or 16,000 men complete in all arms always ready at Aldershot to be sent abroad at a nioment i Forster wishes to sweep ti tio away altogether, absorbing a number of selected battalions into the Home Service Army; but he finds " public opinion" or vested interests too strong for him, and for the time being he proposes only to raise the physical standard and lengthen the period of training—steps which, by choking off recruits, will tend towards the object he has in' view—the extinction of this Auxiliary Force. The Volunteers are to be reduced to 180,000, of whom two-thirds will receive reduced capitation grant, while on third will have an increased grant and will be required to attain a much higher stage of efficiency.

The Militia and the Volunteers.

The groat fight in the Cabinet is understood to have been over the militia; and as a large number os Members of the House of Commons are militia officers there will no d strong opposition to the ab this force, That it will har in the end, however, can hardly be doubted. The militia, Mr. Arnold-Forster, acknowledges, have dono admire able service in the past, and some of them did good service in the recent war in South Africa, But the report of the Esher Committee has shown that as a whole it is not efficient, and if we are to adopt the principle that we do not require a large army of defence, this is the piece which can best be spared. As regards the volunteers, since it is clear that we are paying heavily for men who, though classed "efficient," would be useless in war, there can be no strong objection to reducing the number while Thi however, a strong party with rendering the remainder more efficient.

military "connections which regards the militia as better worth preserving the volunteers, and is persuaded it is only the unpopularity which any Government would earn by doing away with the volunteers that has in-Mr. Arnold-Forster to attack the in preference.

The Position of the Government.

The suggestion that this new army scheme might help to the fall of the Government has already proved utterly baseless. In the first place the scheme will have ho place in practical politics until next year; and by that time, as the War Secretary intimated, changes may have occurred which will place the War Department in quite other hands. In the second place the scheme as a whole will probably gain more supporters from the Liberals than it will lose from the Conservatives, though this will largely depend on the amount of the economy which would be effected by the new scheme. On this point Mr. Arnold-Forster has left us quite in the dark, though he based his scheme primarily on the necessity for cutting down military expenditure. Ha described our army as "one of the cost-of his opponents contend that the saving effected under his proposals would be nothing like in proportion to the reduetion in the number of men.

Mr. Chamberlain and the Liberal Unionists.

Mr. Chamberlain's reorganised Liberal Unionist Council held its first meeting yesterday and he was duly elected its president in the place of the Duke of Devonshire. Hundreds of delegates from Liberal. Unionist Associations all over the country were present in the Imperial Theatre, and the proceedings were enthusiastic and practically unanimous. This largely due to the fact that Liber Unionists who are also Freetrader: refused for the most part to attend, and that Associations containing a majority of Freotraders refused to send delegates. But such Associations are very few, and it is perfectly clear now, if it waa not before, that Mr. Chamberlain has carried the great bulk of the Liberal Unionist Party with him; indeed I doubt if the proportion of Freotraders among Liberal Unionists is much greater than that among Conservatives, Mr, Chamberlain has also made a further groat step towards nobbling the Government. Two Cabinet Ministers, the Marquis of Lansdowne and the Earl of Selborne, were elected Vice-Presidents of the new Association, and Mr.. Victor Cavendish—the, Duke of Devonshire's heir—and Sir Savile Crossley, junior members of Mr. Balfour's Administration, also, received honorary offices, while in the. evening Lord Lansdowne' spoke on the same platform as Mr. Chamberlain, 80 Those objects wore att ed by confining the resolutions to Mr.

Balfour's fiscal proposals, including more ' sympathy with Mr, Chamberlain's preference scheme, but no one can doubt that the now organisation is intended to throw all its energies into the cause which Mr. Chamberlain in fighting.

Mr. Kruger, The sudden death of Mr. Kriiger in Switzerland, has inspired a ood deal of sympathy in the country.

ough journals so intensely devoted to Imperialism as the "Globe" can find no good to say of the old man even in death, most of the newspapers do justice to the great qualities which inspired such devotion in his fellow-countrymen. Indeed there are not a few patriotic Englishmen to-day who are fain to admit, as Mr. Winston Churchill frankly declared during the progress of the war, that if they had een in President Kriger's place they would have acted exactly as he did. He declined to give the vote to "outlanders" because he knew that sooner or later the Boers would be submerged. He ought to have known that war would only produce the same result far more quickly; but Englishmen, now that the heat of battle.is over, will not blame him very severely for taking up the sword in a hopeless cause, FROM OUR LADY CORRESPONDENT, 18th July.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account