To the Rditar of the "Morta-Cama Dairy News."
Si,—Your issue of Friday, the 26th of May contains a notice from twenty-nine persons calling a special mooting of th ratepayers to pass resolution authori ing our Municipal Council to dispose o! ite electricity department with all plant, ete. in conjunction with the building and construction of tramways in Shanghai, As I have been surprised to find that ratepayers, usually pretty wide-awake, have attached no importance to this notice, 1 ask the hospitality of your columns to enable mo to call the aitention of the ratepayers to this startling proposal and to ask them to assemble in large numbers on the 6th of Ju throw it out. It is doubtful wh proj this could have boon made avywhore but in Shanghai.
Twill ask the ratepayers first of all to consider four propositions bearing on the subject which neither these twenty-nine would-be spolistors nor anyone else can controvert.
First.—It is generally accepted in the west, that all articles and commodities of public necessity such as water and lighting should be supplied and administered by the public authority in the public interest not by private companies for private profit, All these things are monopolies. You cannot have two sets of-waterworks or lighting ina town. It is therefore: proper that such should be in the hands of the public.
Those twetity-nine people may say it ought not to be 80; that private companies can manage these things equally well: but that my proposition is true: they cannot deny.
Tt is clear therefore that if the rator Pevopposing the whole theory, spirit, and jars fall in with this proposal they will
sentiment of all the leading nations of the ould, we in Shanghai go and practice of the nations that we belong 10 tion in recent years has been steadily Secondly.—'he whole trend of legisla-
and: universally' in this direction. One thing-after another has been handed over to municipalities till in may of them—the following are included: education, river pollution, allotments, tramways, water, cities we visit, when we in Shanghai go against municipal enterprise. home on furlough, snd which we praise enthusiastically when we return, no matter what country we have visited, are all cities which owe all their comfort, and conveniences to municipal enterprise. Why then in the name of common sense should we be' asked to hand back one of our undertakings to private ent Does the experience of the whole west count for nothing Thirdly.—Let the ratepayers remember that this tendency incrosses rather than diminishes. We shall be told no doubt that our electric lighting has been inefficient and that a private company could manage it better. Well if that be the case Shanghai must bea singular, as it would be a unique, place. It is not true of any other place, The population of all other great cities are rescuing these natural monopolies, the supply of the elemental conditions of existence from private corporations. Surely they know which is most efficient? If private management were the better why is London wrestling to set herself free from private monopolists in water supply?
London is conservative in politics, but progressive in municipal matters, because a long and bitter experience has told her that in the old bad days of the companies she was badly served and extortionately charged.
Fourthly.—Thore are, as far as I know "no examples of any cities whatever handing back to private companies of their municipal undertakings." There may be an odd one here and there, but they can be of no weight against the countless instances in the other direction. compa That they often do so st Universally cities are buying out the
enormous cost makes the fact the more significant. Not one of them would dream of acting as we are to be asked to act! Would Liverpool or Birmingham sell their magoificont waterworks Would Glasgow sell its tramway system she would never dream of it.
The Americsus, British, French, mans are unanimously in favour municipal control, how is that if municipal control is so inefficient as those who are meaking "dead set ab it in Shanghst tell us These four propositions I submit to the ratepayers. They are statements 0° fact that cannot be denied. T ask the rater pryers to think the matter over, to ask themselves why they should take what all recent experience slows would by a retrograde step, without precedent in the home countries, The men who are secking to get hold of this electric lighting department see: profit in it We may be quite sure of that, But if it can worked at a profit for private company in eonjunetivn with tramways," why in the world cannot it be worked at a profit by the Municipal Com cil "in conjunction with tramways" in the public interest? I expect we shall be told that so far the electric lighting in Shanghai has not been " success. The remedy however is not that proposed. If] any department of @ man's business has been mismanaged he does not remedy it by selling the busTaess but by changing his manager. If our Muni Municipal Council is sally as incompetent as this proposal implies, the \edy is to change our municipal coun. Gillors, wot to sell. the electrical business. Might it not be suggested to some of these lemon that they should enter the public interest tin inlets they are now municipal Council and use there in the
Tat ie what bappeowat homes PF reposing to employ for private profit No doubt the arguments relied on will be those that did service s year ago, taken electric lighting, eas, etc. The splendid from the articles in the London " Times"
In regard to those I will only observe, [frst, that the " Times" is uniformly on the side of private monopolies.
Second, that those articles, which seem to have impressed some local minds s0 profoundly, have made no impression in London at all where the spirit in which they were written is thoroughly understood. The London County Council goes on compelling the water companies to hand over their properties, running municipal steamboats on the Thames, laying down miles of electric tramways, opening parks, etc., ote. with the full support of the ratepayers of all parties who pay no attention to the dismal warnings of the impotent "Thunderer" as to municipal extravagance and incompetence. Why should these articles be considered such oracles in Shanghai? I again ask the ratepayers to weigh the matter well and not permit the private speculator to lay his band on an enterprise which increasingly universal theory and practice has decided should belong to the public and be run in the public interest only.
T am, ete, E. Danwenr, 30th May.
To the Editor of the "Nonru-Onmma Darcy Nuws.'
Sm,—It may be presumptuous for mo to attempt to reply to your esteemed correspondent in regard to the proposed mooting of ratepayers, but hope I may be pardoned even if I prove myself to be in the class with those "who rush in where angels dare not tread."
In the first place I must take issue on the expression regarding spoliators, at does my reverend and revered brother mean? That the signers of this call are hoping to make something out of the sale of the electric plant? Certainly this cannot be, for the signers are among our most respected citizens, Where then does the spoiling come in unless the decision of the ratepayers is a foregone conclusion? And this it cannot be. In the next place one cannot say that, because one signs the call for a meeting, necessarily in favour of {he proposition to be voted on. It is often of groat advantage te have matters discussed, for through such discussion features may be brought to light that will improve the situation. For instance. if this matter is fully discussed we may find out that the Municipal Council has been neglectful in its management of the electric plant, And we may find out the why and wherefore of such neglect. I have heard it said that, if members of the Council held stares in the Gas Compan; they might not care to improve the plant, would not for a moment have you infor that such was the case, but would em. hasise the "if." Now allow me to make nef referrnee to the four propositions, West that all articles any! commodities sack First.—Is it generally accepted in
as water and light, should be supplied and administered by the public authority "Tu the forther west, America, an far ax my information goes, water la almost univer applied and administered by public but city lighting plants are very and I know vf no city that owa tramways. uch has been the experience of American cite that it is still' an open, question there whether it would n he more economical to have the water private control wider the Proper restrictions. And it is not an unheard-of event to have two or even three competing lighting companies in the same
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.