The Archive · 1904

A Wonderful Unanimity

Next morning, however—tho morning was intended, it appears, not as a warning to Mr. Chamberlain but as a rapprochement, Such sudden unanimity could not be accidental. The " tip" must have come from some one. Was it from the side of Mr. Balfour's or from that of Mr. Chamberlain? For my part I think there is abundant internal evidence that it was Mr.

Chamberlain or his fellow-workers in the fiscal campaign who inspired the unauimity. It is clear, I think, that Mr. Balfour did intend his speech in some measure as a warning. Mr. Chamberlain does not mean to act on that warning, and it is his cue to minimise as much as possible the difference between his policy and Mr. Balfour's until he has the upper hand. Hence, he resolved to welcome Mr. Balfour's speech as a great "step in advance;" and ho therefore inspired someone to give a quiet hint to those Unionist journals which were rendering his position difficalt by taking the opposite view of the Prime Minister's meaning, A Repndiation of Protection.

Mr. Balfour began his speech by stating that he adhered absolutely to the Sheffield Programme. He declared that it was "self-contained whole," and not a "compromise" or a "half-way house." Indeed he gave a far more lucid exposition of his Sheffield programme than he has ever given before. But then he went on to declare that "true Protection" was not in his opinion the best policy for the country, and that if the Unionist Party should take up a Protectionist line he did not think he could continue to lead it. If he had stopped here there might be better ground for Mr. Chamberlain's talking about "such a change sud reform of the Tariff as Mr. Balfour and myself propose;" but Mr. Balfour went further. He defined what he meant by "true Protection." It is, he said, "a policy which nims at supporting or creating home industries by raising home prices." Now there are two sides of Mr. Chamborlai poliey—the Imperial side, which he generally keeps for perorations, and the home side; and that home comes unmist"kably within the defini of Protection given by Mr. Balfoar. It is to protect the home producer against the "unfair" competition of the foreigner; and that this Protection will raise prices Mr. Chamberlain candidly admits.

The Proposed Colonial Conference.

Finally Mr, Balfour declared himself in favour of Colonial Conference, and ce he declined a si made by Mr. Champs days of last Session, This is in one sense an advance towards Mr, Chamberlaiv. But it must be observed that it is to be a "free conference." We are to enter into it without giving a pledge of our willingness to modify our Free Trade policy. In the second place it is not to be called until after a General Election, and, in the third place, its conclusions are to be submitted to the country at another General Election before they are adopted. Now Mr. Chamberlain has confessed again and again—even quite recently—his conviction that the Liberals will win the next General Election. It is at the next but one that he hopes to triumph. Therefore the Conference cannot be held until after two General Elections, and Preferences cannot come into force until after three. That means twelve years at least, by which time Mr. Chamberlain, if he is spared, will be in his eightieth year. No wonder Mr. Chamberlain describes this as a" blemish " in the plan, and that Liberals see in it a deliberate attempt on his part of the Premier to burke Mr. Chamberlain's proposals.

The Luton Meeting.

Apart from his references to Mr. Balfour's speech there was nothing new in Mr. Chamberlain's Luton address. It was very carefully prepared; it was full of eloquent passages and striking sentences but the matter was old. The meeting was, however, a remarkable one. It was held in a hall built specially for the oceasion—mainly at the cost of the Duke of Bedford—and its demolition was begun soon s the meeting was over—the more hastily perhaps because Mr. Lloyd George had shed for the use of it for a great Liberal meeting. It held sume 7,000 people, and except that it was built of wood, it bore no signs of being a mere temporary structure. Luton is, of course, only a small town; but full railway tickets and free meals were provided for all who would attend from the surrounding districts. It is the only meeting which Mr. Chamberlain addresses for some considerable time, as he is just off on a six-weeks' tour in Italy.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account