The Archive · 1924

Furniture and Photography

Plaintiff claimed that the fur ture handed over by him to defendant had never been returned, but defend-fant denied this altogether and said hho had no property of plaintiff's his possession at the present time. There was no evidence that plaintif? or his attorney ever handed any furniture to defendant. If anybody had charge of it, it was the man who held the power of attorney, Santa Ram, and his Lordship could not see that there was any evidenc> at all to support the statement that this or any furniture was handed over by anybody to defendant. The fact that defendant might have been resent when some of it was removed did not carry the case any further, for it was quite possibi the parties then being on very. friendly terms, that defendant did assist Santa Ram to remove the furniture. Nor did the statement: of plaintiff that he saw some of the furniture in defendant's house when he came back carry the matter any further.

With regard to the photographic materials, said to be of very considerable value, his Lordship said he found himself in the same difficulty. There was very little evid-fence that this enormous amount of very valuable photographic mater-was ever in defendant's possession. There was evidence that he had some—and defendant admitted this—but no evidence that he had fall, Defendant said that he was ven about $60 worth of it but that he could not sell it at that price and afterwards returned it. His Lordship concluded that there was rno.reason why the defendant's story. that there was some sort of settlement some time after plaintiff's return from India should not be The Bank Deposit.

The third item was more dif-' ficult, There was no doubt that at. the time of his arrest plaintiff possessed a bank deposit receipt from fendant took out a deposit receipe his own name for the same Jamount of money and that amount remained unfit January of this year.

September of last year the Bank informed plaintiff what had happened to it, but it was not until January that application for the money was made to defendant through a lawyer. Defendant's explanation was that he purchased the deposit note for case ud an Lou. No documentary evid-fence existed at all, defendant ex-laining that the parties had a general statement after plaintiff? feame back and that all documents existing at that time were destroyed, If it was impossible for pi to cash the deposit receipt in Shang hai before he left for India, his Lordship saw no reason why plain tif should not have taken it witl him, this Bank having branches in India,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account