The Archive · 1904

The Alhambra Case

Sth December

We note with great sarisfu tion hac at las: the Council have puislishthe spandencs int on pati 2 roprabed persians that have been cast on them by writers sedulously primed with one side of the story, feeling that it was more dignified and better in every way to suspend publication until the documents were complete, As now published, the correspon dence begins witha letter from the Senior Consul, dated the 18th of October, asking for an explanation of a raid made on the Alhambra on the L4: h of October, " without any warrant from the Consul concerned." The Council reply with a long explanatory letter dited the 20th of October, explaining that on the 16th of July the Consul for Spain formally empowered the Police to enter and search the building and seize all gambling apparatus, the Consul, Castilla, adding the words: ©Phis warrant will stand until further notice in writing from me." It was well known that gambling continued almost openly at the Alhambra, the lessee Mr. Schwartz, a Spanish protege, successfully defying the police and the apparent efforts of his Consul to suppress gambling. Thes" efforts are indicated by the following sentence passed by Mr. Custillo on the 29 h of August "Moses Schwartz is hereby ordered to stop at once public gambling in the Alhambra Hotel. All the gambling apparatus in his possession will be confiscated unless he gives proper assurances to this Court that they will not be used for illicit purposes during his residence here in Shanghai.

"The Police are hereby asked to investigate in company with a deputy of this Consulate if public gambling is learned on after ti at the Alhambra Hotel. If it is still continued they are ordered to arrest all the Spanish subjects concerned and to confiscate sil the gambling apparatus found there."

Having granted a full warrant to the police, the Spanish Consul made a condition that when a raid wag made, a deputy appointed by self must accompany them on their visits of search, the result of whish, as the Consul must have foreseen if he lid. not been so ingenuously devoted to strict legality, was that one or two raids were fruitless, Mr. schwartz having been forewarned. On the 15th of October it was determined to make another raid, the Consul having a week before " stated his willingness to send a deputy when asked by the police, and warned the police not to enter the premises unaccompanied." How the Spanish Conul carried out his promise to send deputy when asked is shown by what occurred on the 15th. The Captain-Superintendent of Police called personally on Mr. Castilla at 1030 p.m.—it being obviously useless to raid a place like the Alhambra, which is essentially a night-house, in the daylight—and the Corsui reimsed to him. The dinsiy acted on the ware Vonsul, which kal never teen With: saa. pei given them by vie

drawn, and mid: t'e raid whose impropriety turned th? Consular Body pale with horror, 'The Consular Body in general, and the Spani in' particular, ympathi ant approve the efforts of the Couxcil to suppress gambling and other disorders, and the Council therefore were only carrying out the wishes of the Consular Body and the ratepayers generally. They hed an ample warrant from the Spanish Con-ul, as its text shows Consulate for Spain Shanghai, 16th July, Sin,—You are empowered by this rant to enter and search any Spanish-owned house of public entertainment on the roads out of the Shanghai Intorational Settlements where yo ublic gambling is being carried on therein, bling apparatus and spanish ject found operating gambling apparate Tnis warrant will stand until farther notice in writing from me, Tam, Sir, Your obedient servant, H. G, vex Casrinto, Consul.

To the Carrain-SurenixpesDENt, Municipal Police, after the Spanish Consul had gmvited such a warrant as this, authorising the potice " to lenter awl sear Spanish-owned house of pul rtaimment out of the Shunghai International Settlements," the objections raised by the Consular Body at the instance of the Spwish Consul, to the action Council, as far as regards nbra being situated outside the limits of the Setilement, are little better than bunkum, if we may say so with al] respect to the members of that august Bidy,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account