The Archive · 1912

DR. GILBERT REID'S REPLY

Dr. Gilbert Keid writes: "a correspondent writing from Peking, expresses his views on various topics, and avails himself of the opportunity to assail some views of my own on the above topic The references to myself are of such character that I had better consider them as a "means of grace, especially in the virtue of humility.

What is the attitude of my critic towards important principles or! to any particular class of people in China, it is not to be expected that one so dull of comprehension as myself can possibly understand. In consequence my reply must be of a very casual character.

In pleading for justice to the Manchus, I'am informed that approval of Peking'—certainly a pretty large body of humanity to come down on one poor head. Up to the present my head feels the blow of only When the full force of blow of million people for mercy as well as justice.

correspondent," so far as I can judge, does not like my " document," because he does not like the Manchus—a part of Peking. Therefore he scorns both of the methods I mention for securing Manchu representation, viz. representation as a people or as territory. They will have a share in the government, we are informed, '"'according to their qualification." But] how is that to be attained, if they are to have no representation as people or a territory? If qualification is essential, how is it that all of a sudden the Manchus drop so far below the other four races that! not one representative can be! found? And if Manchu identity is to be destroyed, why continue the talk of unity between the "five races"? Ts it for the peace of the whole country to aim at absorption Even if possible, is it just? Because I plead for some form of giving justice, I am a little surprised that all Peking is up in arms, including even my-Manchu, friends.

In one part of the letter I am considered to be in collusion with the Manchus, and even with Mr. Secretary Knox; in another, I am in collusion with the revolutionists. Whether such juggling belongs to "the best" or to "mistaken" or whether it corresponds to my past record, I leave to others to decide. In the meantime, I confess I have been and still am, (which means much more) a friend of the Manchus. I believed that abdication was the only thing to bring war to an end, and I believed that in the end, if the revolutionists acted justly, the Manchus would be benefited, as well as the whole country. To hint that abdication was a mistake, is to imply that the new government with peace is worse than the Manchu government with continuance of bloodshed. In fact, " a correspondent" is a friend no more of the Republic than of the Manchus. According to his own acknowledgement, he commends an "'autocracy," whicl " pleasantly gloved." This accounts for his opposition to my modest "lament."

Another point: " What right had Dr. Reid to give assurance to the Manchus of any particular kind of treatment?" On the word of honour of those who gave the assurance made to the whole world, is my Later on, Yuan Shih-kai lar terms of liberal treat-

A correspondent" affirms that supporters of the Republic never intended to do as they promised, and, I must also conclude information that Yuan has the same intention.

Should this be the case there is all the more need for some one to plead for "justice for the Manchus,"" even in the face of "the severe disapproval of Peking" and "a correspondent." Help to the majority of Manchus, now bereft, matter of both compassion and Another question remai other than Manchv needs, or, if attempted, will it succeed? Now that the Manchu rule is ended, I for one prefer that earnest efforts be put forth to carry into effect _a_constitutio:.al repuvlig) With: uri mong all the

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account