The Archive · 1912

THE RED EROSS SOCIETY OF CHINA

To the Editor of the "Norts-Cumxa Datty News."

Dr. Gilbert Reid's reply to my former letter shows such a lack of knowledge of facta aa makes it difficult for me to reply in the limited space available in newspaper correspondence columns. May I be allowed to clear up one matter which will, by inference, help to explain the whole situation? In May, 1911, Mr. Shen Tun-ho, Director of the Shanghai Branch of the Red Cross Society of China, visited Peking, interviewed the President of the Society, Mr. Sheng Huan-huai, and was appointed by Mr. Sheng Delete to the Washington Conference.

is appointment was confirmed by the Waiwupu and conferences were held between Mr. Shen and representatives of the Waiwupu. At o of these conferences note was made of the fact that the Head Office of the Society was in Peking and the Branch Office in Shanghai.

This was the status when the revolution broke out. Within a short organizing work in districts wi Still remained under the old government, while at the same time he lent every possible assistance not only to Mr. Shen, but to other Red Cross organizations not controlled by Mr. Shen. It will be seen that the status of the Shanghai Society and of the General Committee can only be determined by considering the status of Mr. Shen, who remains now, as he has been all along, a Director of the Red Cross Society of China. In addition to this, he isa Director of the Shanghai Branch and was, until recently, the Joint President of the General Committee. Mr. Shen was also the regularly appointed Delegate to the W: ington Conference, as stated above.

When he reported to the Peking Government in the jatter part of March that he could ndt go to Washington, President Yuan appointed Minister Chang as representative and later added the names of Mr.

Yung Kwai and myself. As I was on the point of leaving Peking, the President of the Society received communication from the Waiwupu stating that " telegram had been received from Mr. Shen Tun-ho asking that Mr. T. T. Wong should also be appointed. Mr. Lu conseated and the appointment was made by the Waiwupu in the same manner as the former three. The cords of the conferences between Mr. Shen and the Waiwupu held in May, 1911, were furnished to our delegation, and the paper prepared by Mr. Wong was from the official documents of the Government and of the Society.

Dr. Reid will excuse me for re. peating what I thought I bad made clear in my previous letter, i.e., that Mr. Wong did not represent" the Shanghai Society in any other sense than that the Shanghai Society had requested his appointment. He was the representative of the Chinese Government, from which he re ceived the credentials which admitted him to the Conference. Mr.

Shen sent credentials to Mr. Wong, which were not presented by him to the Conference. As a delegate of the Government, he could only follow the instructions of the Govern-time thereafter, on account of the difficulties of the situation and the Tack of a guiding precedent for Red Cross Work during times of _insurrection, the new President of the Society, Mr. Lu Hai-huan, asked me to telegraph Mr. Shen to act independently for the time being. Mr. Shen undertook this responsibil in a genuinely self-sacrificing spirit, At a later date he invoked the help lof the Japanese Red Cross Society, through the Japanese Consul-Gen-He also invited Shanghai residents to form a General Committee, of which he and Sir Havilland de Sausmarez became the ents. During all this time Sm,—Again may I be allowed to) the President of the Red Cross 8o-occupy a amall space in your paper. (ciety of China continued active in ment, and not those of the Shanghai Society.

There are several other mistakes in Dr. Reid's letter, which space will not allow me to point out, but the foregoing facts are a key to the whole situation.

Allow me again to express the hope that the forthcoming convention of Red Cross workers in Chin will settle amicably all those ters which seem to me of minor importance as compared with the great work of philanthropy for which the Society has been organized. There should be no dissensions and it la safe t6 say that there will bbe none after the convention has had an opportunity to look over the records of the Society.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account