The Archive · 1924

$1,600,000 CASE DISMISSED

In the cave of the former treas-wer of the International Finance Exchange Company, Me, who drought a suit in the U.S. Court for China for the appointment of a veeeiver, Mr. H. D. Rodger, on behalf of the defendant, moved to dismiss the plaintiffs petition, "Tu hig argument Mr. Rodger pointed out to the Court that the only relief prayed in the plaintiffs Dill that the Court appoint a receiver to take charge of the affairs of the corporation; no specific claim was made by the plaintiff. Mr. Rodger cited a number of authorities for the defendant in support of the motion. Counsel stated that a. parallel ease had been decided by the 9th Circuit, Court of Appeal, which is the Appeal Court in this tute en-Jarging its powers, a court of equity shag no jurisdiction at the suit of a stockholder or other private person to dissolve a corporation, or to appoint a receiver to control the corporation, the effect of which will be to dissolve it."

The case of Pearce v. Sutherland and alto" the case Brietson Mfg. Ca. v. Close, et al. were referred to as being directly point.

Counsel for plaintiff submitted that the Court must find that the plaintiff did not state sufficient facts in his bill to constitute a cause of action. Further that the bill asked for the appointment of a receiver to take charge of the affairs of the corporation as the primary andi ultimate relief and as such it was beyond the jurisdiction of the court to ovant the same for the reason that this remedy was an ancillary and incidental relief to be granted only' for the purpose of preserving the corpus of the corporation pending decision in an original At the conclusion of the argument the Court made the order that the! plaintiffs bill for the appointment of a receiver be dismissed without pre-indica,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account