The Archive · 1924

Appendicitis Among the Chinese

To the Editor of the "Nonru-Cuina Datty News!

Sm—Among the many absurd! statements made about things in China probably few of them would surpass the one quoted your short} editorial in to-day's issue rel ive to the prevalence of certain in this country.

.To.refer to two of these—eancer of the alimentary canal and appendieitis.

In "The Diseases 6f China"

(1910), of which I had the privilege to bertie ce-author with Dr. Jeffreys: lof Shanghai, we wrote "It should be emphasized that carcinoma of the alimentary tract, from the cardiac fend of the stomach to.the last inches the colon, is extraordinarily rare."

'Of appendicitis we wrote "Appendicitis is extremely rare among' Chinese who donot. subsist foreign food; while in Shanghai it extremely common among foreigners and frequently seen Chinese who keep a foreign table."

have been studying the distr. bution among the Chinese ever since this volume was issued and the Knowledge acquired during these! years gives me little reason to alter' my views on the position here stated. With regard to both these diseases, ample evidence of the truth of the: statements can be got from the rejeords of the very large number of China, however, is a vast country id the more one studies conditions in it the less willing is one to commit oneself to generalizations. While undoubtedly the above are the facts over a large part of the country we have reports from time to time of greater prevalence of disease in certain areas. This is so about appendicitis, There is one small rea where it is reported to be found among Chinese in a proportion not far below that found in western Innds. This statement remains' still to be completely verified. The: fact is quite certain that in the bulk of reports from skilled observers! scattered all over China appendicitis among the Chinese is reported as being comparatively very rare, while its incidence among foreigners is strikingly common, Tam, ete., Iasies L. Maxwent.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account