The Archive · 1905

PURE BLOOD

Pure Blood and a Clear Skin

Seopa zie, wanen the: Lisees pending. The evidence this subject goes far to remove any suspicion resting on the plaintiff's claim' merely by the delay, and it also goos to show that when the defendant left for Singapore his financial position was not satisfactory as he wishes to make out.

I think the plaintiff rebutted the presumption which her signing the written acknowledgment of the loan raised against her, and that it devolved on the defendant.

ow that the loan was actually made, some length into the Plsitifs evidence because that was, not jone in the judgment of the Court below, where it appeared to be assumed that the, burden of proof lay on the defendant from the beginning, and Counsel for the. defendant rightly argued that this wag. not so. In the petition of Appeal, which was not drawn by the Counsel who argued in support of the Appeal, it is contended that brought by the plaints" was not admissible to contradict her written acknowledgment, but Mr. White Gooper frankly admitted that he could not sustain that contention. But he pointed out, that the evidence in contradiction ought to be of the strongest character that the circumstances would he carefully cutised the to show discrowhich ought. Having given, ions against it, I think th such as to make it incumbent on the defendant to prove that the loan was actually made, and I agree with the. conclusion arrived at by the Judge of the, Court below and by his Assessors that the defendant has failed to give any satisfactory proof of the money having been paid to the pi The story of his having. sold jewellery and of his keeping the proceeds of the sale in dollars in " cupboard, in inherently improbable and its improbability is confirmed by the evidence, which, it appears to mo was rightly admitted, to rebut his evidence on the point,, The Judge below and the Assessors, having all the parties before them, were in a better position than I am to judge of the, credibility of the witnesses, an@ I should hesitate to disagree with them where the matter was in doubt.

But the conclusion defendant's own evidence is quite untrustworthy. I think the case was rightly, decided on the evidence. an application Stoats on behalf of the Before the appeal came on for hearing,

appellant -to call one Cheang Jih as a. witness on the hearing of the appeal. Though not without considerable hesitation, Irefased the application." Mr. White,, Cooper in ropportof the applieasion fled. statement then that

improbability. The defendant saya thet Blow kun isnot open to the objection of 1,000 dollars to Chan

he never received the amount. It la not she purposes of this caso.to mbathoc ba did oF not. The ante em he, of 4 seveninh question releted tothe 4,000, the, sum.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account