Nov. 14.
IN these beautiful autumn days it is difficult to feel depressed about anything. But really the condition of China is} deplorable. This is the best] answer to Mr. R. ¥. Lo's long! letter published yesterday, defending Feng Vu-hsiang's coup] tat. We- do not wish to weary our readers with a matter on which the majority have long, since made up their minds, nor have we the' least intention of being involved in meshes of metaphysical argument. The] main point at issue is quite clear. If Feng committed an act of treachery in turning against Wu when the latter was least able to defend himself "(which Mr. Lo does not appear to admit), then, says our correspondent,.he lid evil that good might come, considering that his duty to Wu was below his duty to his countrymen and the call to him to stop the war. We took this point, by the way, when first writing about the coup and it to be decided by a simple test. Has, Feng's action succeeded? Does it show, the slightest si of succeeding? Is there any symptom of the country being} bettered by it? The answer is surely and emphatically, no.
To such a state of affairs has the political, situation been reduced that it is at present] impossible to see any line by which the country might be guided out of the mess, Marshal Chang is in Tientsin surrounded by large forces. He went there, we are told, to consult Marshal Tuan Chi-jui who is*thought to be an acceptable figurehead behind) whom - all might persuaded to pull together for the propulsion of the ship of state, But Marshal Tuan shows; /no inclination to be a figure-head. He dreams of some panacea of his own and it is even hinted that he has material forces at his command to enable him to stand out independently as its champion. Feng Vu-hsiang, having vainly tried to persuade Chang and Tuan to go to Peking! to see him, surrendered and went to Tientsin to see them, thus tacitly "accepting the subordinate position which only they would allow him. We are told that something happened here to alarm Feng and that he has fled. If this be true, is he in the wilds, or back in Peking, preparing to resist Marshal Chang's advance on the capital, while his henchman Dr. C.
Wang, indites "mandates" cashiering some of supposely, best friends? Meanwhile on the Yangtze Marshal Chi not} unnaturally issues orders that no notice is to be taken of said mandates, Wu Pei-fu hovers somewhere between Chefoo and Wuchang and other Yangtze Tuchuns, behind a pretended mutual understanding to keep the peace in their own province exhibit unmistakeable signs of taking whatever line of country suits them best. What hope can we find here of unifying China whether by force or otherwise?
Meanwhile, it is impossible to ignore the inroads which the sinister Bolshevik is making in various parts of China. Naturally he gives special attention to, and has proved most successful in, those parts where government is least worthy of the name. The! tyrannical yet weak and _ineffective despotism of Dr. Sun Yat-sen in South China has offered the Soviet a chance by which it was not slow to profit. In Peking the ridiculous administration of General Feng's so-called cabinet, based as it is on nothing but" revolution, opens! another door. If the Chinese people are only moderately well governed, their native sagacity' and immemorial philosophy of life would prove an impenetrable armour against Bolshevism. But, we cannot be blind to the fact that the hand of government everywhere is growing more and more shadowy, as tuchuns and district officials find themselves increasingly occupied with the doings of their neighbours, to the neglect of affairs in their own domains.
Perhaps the worst feature in the whole situation is that none of the rival leaders appears. to advocate a policy which finds any response in the wishes of the people. They move hither and thither with their armies over the surface of the nation but totally unconnected with it. Now id. then one of them "defeated" and his army attaches itself to his conqueror, while the defeated man bobs up in a new place—like Lu Yung-hsiang, exile and execrated from Shanghai, but now in high preferment in this way, it oppe that any leader or body of 1 ers, will ever succeed in imposing his will on the others; nor, if he did, can we think that his will would have aught of popular approval to support it. We. are not talking of the
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.