Defendant, giving evidence, said that the did'not know Mr. Lindsay He was introduced to him inv 1918 und had seen him in th bank, but beyond passing the time of day when they met they were not intimate, Witness had seen this particular dog: for months, but hho had not the faintest idea to whom it belonged. He owned two Alsatans and a fox terrier. He had been considerably troubled with this "half-bred monkish sort of dog" since November 24. In the case of another dog who wise annoyed him. the knew the owner and personally complained to him. Had he known the other belonged to Mr. Lindsay he would also have complained to him. It frequently. broke through Wis bamboo fence, which he had to repair in at least 12 place Sihiped Mim ey night ud eas bye awake until 3am. He had thrown stones at it and beaten it with a stick. @nce after he had driven it away it returned at 3.30 am, and that was when he first fired at it, After that he saw it several times trying to get into his garden, Oh the evening of Decem—ber 8 witness went to investigate a complaint made by Ws boy and found two coolies armed with bam-Boos and a dog preventing them getting to the greenhouse. One footle said that the dog had bitten him." Witness called to the " dog and as it growled at him he went. to fetch his rifle. Returning, he again called to the dog, but it showed its teeth and looked es though was going to spring at him, s0 the fired, He confidered at the time that it was absolutely necessary to shoot, in order to defend himself. Having. fired. the first hastily and wounded the animal, as he thought, in the shoulder, he took careful aim for a second shot, in order to put the dog out of misery and then a third to make sure. He only fired three shots. At first he thought that it was a black and white dog, but at a subsequent examination found that it ad a white patch through having rubbed against a newly painted cold-frame.
Witness repeated that he thought it was necessary to shoot in eelfdefence. The police had been issuing, warnings about rabies and he did not intend to be bitten: by a strange dog.
Mr. Martin Little's Dog time he make any inquiries whom it belonged. Some months ago he complained to the French police about another dog (he be Hioved' it was Mr. Martin Little's) which strayed into his garden, and hho told them that he would shoot if it repeated the offence. They told him he was quite right. He had not made any complaint to Mf 'Martin Little. Mr. Martin Little' dog had done serious damage to his Alsatian puppy.
Mr, Gregson—Will you deny thet you abused Mr. Martin Little and threatened his dog?—I have never spoken to Mtr. Martin Little in my Mr, Gregson—t shall ask for Mr. Mart'n Little to be called on that, It shows what sort of a person the defendant is, and the attitude he adopts with regard to dogs.
'Anawering further questions, the defendant said that the dog' appeared to be mad. The body wi buried. He did not know whether the dog had a collar on.
The Magistrate—Were not you interested in finding out whose dog was, or, if it had rabies, in sending it to be examined?—I - don't say it had rabies.
The Magistrate—Well, was it not necessary to vend it to the Munteitome Have you a this dog was Mr. doubt it.
Where is the dog buried? Can you find its collar? Tt was hurfed your garden?—TI will ask my eer-Vants if they took the collar off. There is another dog very similar it running round about the Del lento, Why had you not the curiosity to ce what dog you had shot?—It did not occur to me.
Why not?—Beoause I recognized it as the one I had seen 20 often.
Could you at any time say when ther it had a collar?—I cannot remember. It never occurred to me examine it so carefully. I examined it carefully after Mr. Lindsay had been in.
Well, had it a collar?—I cannot sey.
Do you mean to say, if there wes anything in what Mr. Lindsay had said, that you did not look for a collar? Would it not be the natural thing t look for a eollar?—Is did not occur to me, 'A Sort of Crossbred What exactly do you mean by a monkish dog?—A sort of crossbred.
When the dog, as you say, adopted a threatening attitude, why did not you send for the police?—That would have taken time, and I wanted to get at my greenhouse.
Now, did you shoot Wim because had' annoyed you, or because you were frightened of him?—I shot him because he took up such a menacing attitude.
Mr. Grogson—On that I should like to ask Mr. King this—"When you shot the dog before, when you admit you wounded it, was it because you were annoyed, or because you were afraid of it?'—That occurred about 8.80, after I had driven it out of the garden, and hed gone down in my dressing-gown and put boards up. I fired at such a dis tance that I thought it would not} vitally injure him.
The Magistrate—Then the answer fs that you fired because he annoyed you?—No, because he was doing [damage to my property.
Defendant's house-boy and gardener also gave evidence, alleging that the dog was a frequent tres-asser, that it was of a fierce disposition and showed fight when attempts wore made to drive it away, The gardener said that in the scene on the night when it was shot it] tore Lis trousers but "did not dito him. He did not know to whom
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.