At Wednesday's hearing, Mr. Schuhl, in his submission to [the Judge, said the case was quite clear. The building was owned by the defendant and sub-let to the Carlton Cafe. Mr. Bell had said that his company was doing certain work for the Cafe in order that they might open up aa certain time. The Jwork was started, but it could not finished at once owing to the fact that certain of the Shanghai Municipal Council's regulations had not been complied with. This involved certain extra work and extra expense, and somebody had to pay for it, The Asia Engineering Com-Jpany could not be expected to carry lout plumbing work, put in pipes, ete., [just for fun. They had to be paid, fand he submitted defendants were {the parties responsible. It was quite certain the work had not been order-
Jed by the Carlton, Ld., and he suggested it was impossible to believe Mr. Bell in his statement that, though he was on the premises for half a day every day when the worl was in progress, he yet knew nothing about it—not "even it was being carried out. Ay they had Mr. Sargent' that he received his instructions to jerry on with the work from Mr. Bell. In these circumstances judgment should be given for plaintiff {in the total amount asked for.
Mr. Snyder contended that' Mr. 'Schuhl presumed too much when he libeld that any work done on certain premises, whether done with the Jowner's consent or not, should be Jat the the owners' expense. The person or persons who authorized [that this work should be done was ithe person responsible, and it had not been proved that defendants were responsible. No evidence had been brought which could reasonably be taken to mean that they had accepted responsibility. They knew nothing: about tt.
The Judge summed up at length, dealing with each item separately.
held that plaintiffs were entitled to recover the sum of Tls. 2,281.50 Jonly, and gave judgment for that
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.