The Archive · 1924

Fisher Unwin. London. 1924

This is very readable and interesting record of close upon half a century of life spent in China and will be of special interest to those who know little or nothing of the inner workings of the Customs. Service, Although the author has been at pains (p. 22) to emphasize that Ite is not "that unhappy mortal, a man with a grievance," strong' undercurrent of resentment at the treatment he received at the hands of the Into Sir Robert Hart goes far to belie his protest, The early part of the book deals with or. dinay incidents in outport life, such as were probably common to the majority of those who were in China in those days. The narrative becomes more historically interesting when the author comes to describe political crises in. thi country; with the men who had time to deal with them, and more pecially with the critical days of the Servi porarily without Boxer uprising, when the Customs

head. We think that Mr. King ha been a little less than just in criticising the Statistical Seeretary (Mr. F. E. Taylor) for not having assumed charge of the Service at once and without bothering his head about local officials or Consular officers. He forgets, apparently, that while it was quite competent for the Viceroy of the Liang Kuang to put the Canton Commissioner in temporary charge of the treaty ports under his Jurisdiction after making local Provision for the necessary funds for carrying on those Customs. Houses, it was imperative that the Statistical Secretary should obtain the support of all the Treaty Power Consuls for authority to. draw upon Customs funds lodged in the banks required for the maintenance of the Service in general. It is also unfair to suggest that the acceptance by the Statistical Secretary of the appointment as Oficlating Inspector General by the Nanking Viceroy—at the instigation, be it remembered, of the Consular Body in Shanghai—was any more indicative of overhaste in at tempting to step into dead men' shoes than was the author's own acceptance of the imperium en imperia vested in him by Li Hung-chang. Moreover, the use of the term Ofc in Customs par-Tanee, connotes merely temporary, occupation of a post properly belonging to another.

The summary of Sir Robert Hart's character in Chapter XX is probably as fair as could be expected from any one who could not know him intimately and could only judge him by-his.actions as the head of very cosmopolitan service. using the word "Simma" (p. 49) in connexion with a well known member of a certain section of Shanghai society in the '80's the author has evidently overlooked the genesis of the expression he had in mind, which was jokingly com-1 letters of the Shanghai 'Young Men's Mutual Admiration Society; hence it would have been more' corceet to write of one of the Symmas. We have noted a few clerical errors, such as Pantaloon, for Pantaloon and Cousins for Cousens (p. 83) and Olsen for Oiesen (p. 225), and we wonder if the name Hayllar (p. 70) should not have been Hayter?

If, as the book purports to be, this'is the first account of life in the Chinese Customs Service by one of its members, let us hope that the example thus set may be followed by. many others who have doubtless just as interesting a story to tell, and more especially those, whose numbers are steadily diminishing, whose memories can carry them hack to, the good old days outport life. Tt is to be hoped also

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account