The Archive · 1925

Mr. R. S, Haskell for intervener

In asking for a fresh trial, Me.' Haskell said that in his mind the evidence of S.C. Young was not! true.

The Judge here reminded counsel that he (Mr. Haskell) was absent by intent. The witness who said he was S. C. Young, with his head tied up, might have palmed himself off to be 8, C. Young. In any case he curried no weight as far as he: (Gudge Purdy) was concerned. There was reliable evidence to show that the metal taken from the Arsenal by defendants was the property of China.

Tu answer to his Honour, Mr. Schuhl said the property which was the subject of the dispute had been returned to the Arsenal.

The Judge—Well, then, Mr.

you have no standing in this. Court. What good does it do you to sue again? This Court has no power to recover the property. It Is beyond its jurisdiction.

Mr. Haskell replied that the intervenor and the Kiangnan authorities had been in negotiation with a view te reaching a settlement. His client had said that everything was all ight. He would not have to appour. Intervenor had received, Mr. Haskell went on, Tls. 10,000 as' part Tayment for the goods.

The Judge—Your client ix lucky then.

Mr. Jones produced sworn statements that no settlement had been arrived at and that, to his best knowledge and belief, the witness, mentioned at pre' who had connexion action. The directors of the En-neering & Shipbuilding Ca., also tered an affidavit that they had paid Tls. 10,000 Judge Purdy dismissed the motion.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account