The Archive · 1925

AN ACTION AGAINST GINLING COLLEGE

Chinese Contractor's Claim for 99,157: "Taking-

Continuing, Dr. Mei said plainuff had guaranteed. the contractor, tone Woo, who had since disappeared. [Sudgment hail recently been secured fat the Mixed Court for about Tls. 2000 from the present plaintiff, because the work had not been performed according to contract. Dr. Dalbey had entered-a counter-claim in the U.S. Coure for Tls. 2,500.

Plaintiff in giving evidence stated that both he contractor, Woo, and defendant were members of the Seventh Day Adventist Church. They met and discussed plans for building the house. He was a Jsubscriber to the Christian Church. He tried many times to collect the remainder and also. the extras, amounting to Tls. 3,604.

In eross-examination Mr- Fleming, for defendant,, put it. to witness that he. told Dalbey, September 1923 that he would collect for extras, but in December of the same year, when the original complaint Was filed he no mention of any extras. Tt was since opposing counsel had taken charge of the case that in the amended petition extras were pleaded. Witness replied that it was only afier consultation with the arbitrator that he had thought of extras, Further evidence was heard by Judge Purdy at the U. S. Court} fon Tuesday in the action of Messrs. Ah Hong r. the Board of Trustees of the University of Nan: king, Plaintiff alleges that. Tls. 9,187 is due him to complete payments for his work on the buildings of Ginling College in Nanking.

Mr. C. S. Franklin appeared for plaintiff: Mr. 1, S. Snyder for defendant.

Replying to Mr. Franklin, Mr. Filiot Hazzard, representing the architects, Messrs. Murphy, McGill Har in, strived that he had received itten' orders to alter the found-ions. They were signed by Mri.

Jatilda Thurston, president of the institution, and the contractor had, jearried out the alterations as in-

Corroborative evidence by Mr. H. Keys, who at that time was also Jconnected with the firm of architects, ted Inter that the corrected plans new ascertain the difference in the Jconerete used—there was less under the new specific at ing off," 1 deductions from plans, he ha sented his Sgures to Ah Hong, who though advised to check 1 cepted them as correct. witness continued, had made a triple: Jcheck to assure their correctness. Mrs. Thurston told him she thought the difference would be still As was his duty for the are! hho had signed a certificate of accentance and as Mr. Murphy—Mrs. Thurston wished to consult him fore final settlement—had delayed his trip to Shanghai, finally signed the certificate authorizing payment to the contractor.

Other evidence will be taken upon Mrs. Thurston's return from New!

York.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account