6th June.
Brown.—You must acknowledge my dear Smith, that there are some things which are better done by the Municipality or the State than by private enterprise, For example, 7 never yet heard of any country sting a good system of roads and streets made without the combined effort of the State. I doubt if there ever existed a thoroughly good national system of education which was established by private effort, and there certainly was never a successfal State which left the defence of its coasts and frontiers to the private individuals living near them.
Suara.—All this," as they say in the Baptismal Service, "I steadfastly believe." But there is a vast difference between road-making, child-training, war-waging, and municipal trading. against the unnecessary that I It is not against the necessary but protest, Rosinson.—I should be glad to know on what principle your protest is based. Do you object to all municipal trading, or only to certain kinds Smairn.—I object to the authorities doing anything that can be done equally well by private individuals, In the case of electricity in particular, it can be shown that the tendency to monopoly on the part of municipal ities has done much to hinder development.
Brown.—That may be. But which is worse, a monopoly held by the ratepayers themselves for their own benefit, or one held by private people for their benefit. At the moment you may pay your money and have your choice, By and by, if you get into the hands of a business-like set of directors, unfettered by competition, you will pay your money, but you will have no choice, Rosrvson.—I was talking to Fiach about the matter this morning, and he thinks we ought to sell because it is not reasonable to expect ordinary tlemen, as our Councillors are, to ow anything about electricity But I told him it would be just as foolish to expect them to know anything about road-making, sewer construction, or concrete pipe-making. Yet they make a tolerable success of all these things. It is not such a very difficult matter in these days to get reliable specialists.
Smara.—And deliver yourselves bound, body and soul, to that bugbear of all freemen—a brow-beating bureaucracy. Look at Russia, just now. Itis not the autocrat against whom curses and bombs are being hurled. It is the bureaucrat, Brown.—That may be allowed, my dear fellow; bub it does not affec
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.