The Archive · 1915

Some Answers from the

BELABOURED CRITIC

It is said that the first thing to be read in @ woman's letter i postscript; and my antagonist's letter shows so many feminine traits, pardonable in a profésiion so markedly neurotic as the school-master' that I begin at the end of his article. One should never delay in reply to 8 polite (1) invitation, but, mindful of various lively interviews with irascible dominies in my vanished youth, I prefer to reply in the classic kines "Kind alr, that may not be!

"T've heard what's in your parlour and I do not wish to see.

My first article shows so much blue-pencilling at his hands and #0 low a percentage gained, that I fear if T accepted his kind invitation to personal interview, I might be welcomed by some such scholas-tie ile as Luther is said to have thrown at the devil.

Neither will I be tempted from my incognito by a writer himself sheltered by anonymity; nor will T inflict any autobiographical details (such as the existence and number of my children) on the long-suffering reader of this discussion; nor will I render myself liable to an action for 1 by mentioning any jer in particular—however sweetly my opponent may "ug "Dilly, dilly, come and be killed." No doubt each school in Shanghai has its good points; I do not hold the appointment of "'ad.-writer" to any, Moreover, praise to one might be tantamount to a condemnation of others. If I say, for instance, that the Jews and the Catholics are notoriously chi ble to their poorer scholars, it might be taken implying that the Municipal (and other) Schools were not. I gather from internal evidence that a Muncipal foreign school appointment is held by my infuriated cut includes in a common condemnation not only myself but Mr. Kirk, who dared to write and the Editor who dared to print Mr. Kirk's opinion that my first "educated article needs neither disclaimer nor apology, but embodies the soundest common sense in things education: that has been published in this Settlement for considerable Period."

Teaching a Trade, I pass over matters of merely personal abuse, and of such rash judgements as that ''both the doctor and teacher in question should have been hanged." If I ever come to trial (absit omen) may I have men on the jury more level-headed and better read in law than my opponent. He shows in other passages the proverbial ignorance of the dominie of the interests of the world of men for which he says he

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account