The Archive · 1905

W. N. Symonds for the defendant

Mr. Symonds said he understood that His Lordship was not prepared to take this case that day. He understood that from enquiry at the registry. Tt would be more convenient if His L-rdship would fix a day; there was " set off, but Mr. Browett's client was not a registered British subject.

Mr. Browett said he had no objection to the case being postponed for a short time.

His Lordship said there was no notice before the Court of any set-off, Mr. Browett remarked that the Court could not adjadiento on, the in Council. Mr. Browett quoted the rule.

according to the now His Lordship replied that that did not refer to a set-off but tos counter-claim. If it was s pure set-off and a defence to the action then he could deal with it. Suppose counsel had " mixed action, was His Lordship to go into the credit side of the action and leave another court to go into the: debit side of the action That would be an absurdity and he would cor-tainly not do it. Up to that time there was no defence filed in this action. Did Mr. Symonds ask for further time Mr. Symonds—Yes, my Lord.

Mr, Browett—As there is no defence, your Lordship, might I ask for an order for judgment for the plaintiff with costs?

Mr. Symonds—Ob, no.

His Lordship—You certainly ought to have filed your defence, Mr. Symonds.

Mr. Symonds said the case was to have been heard in chambers the previous day: but he had no notice served on him that the case was to be hoard in Court that day. He understood that there was no possibility of the case coming on and that a day would be fixed.

is Lordship—Leb the case stand for a week, and you must put yours in order before the end of that week.

Mercaurs A. Cranxe v. H, E. Reyweu This case was a claim for $4,958.56 balance due upon a cheque ' dated Bist December 1904 and for $205 for for si months of cases Highland cream sold to the defendants by the plaintiff on the 2ist of December 1904, and for:$203.60 for interest on the amount of the cheque. The total claim was for $5,367.06.

Mr. Bidoulac appeared for the plaintiff and Mr. Teesdale for Mr. Berigny who is toting us liquidator for Moss Reyoal Mr. Teesdale said that last summer Mr. Berigny came to Shanghai and entered into negotiations with H. E. Reynell & Ca for the purchase of their business. TI! accounts and books were gone into and the business was taken over, During the period when actual negotiations were taking place and of the actual purchase of the business there was a gentleman in char of Messrs Reynell Co's business who seemed to have conducted the business in a very unsatisfactory manner. There had been accounts mis laid and accounts hot written up so that when he had purchased the business Mr. Berigny found claims being made against him which he had no knowledge of during the negotiations. Mr. Berigny was perfectly willing to meet the creditors in every way and Mr. Clarke, the plaintiff but he could not do so in the very short time given him. The plaintiff was covered with a cargo of cream which, if sold at a time when cream was at a fair market there would not be much left to pay. Council asked his Lordship to adjourn the case so that the parties might come to some amicable settlement out of court.

Mr, Bidoulac said 700 cases of creams were in the hands of the plaiuciff, subject to the bank's lien, The plaintiff was not secured so much a3 Mr. lo seemed to think.

Mr. Teesdale said Mr, Berigny admitted he was the suc ce-sor to Reynell & Ca.

Mr. Bidoulac's-it he did not want Mr. Berigny, but Keynel! & Ca. He thought that the parties might come to a settlement. Heasked his Lordship for an ad-cone subject to a short stay of execu-

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account