The Archive · 1905

The Scene in the House

It is difficult at this mo wont for anyone who takes even a perfunctory interest in politics to judge impartially of the regrettable scene which occurred in the House of Commons on Monday. Its effect in lowering the prestige of Parliament has no doubt been exaggerated. One worthy ex-Minister has declared it was the most disgraceful scove witnessed within his forty years' experi-cuon of the House; but although one of easily extenuate the refusal of the waulw Opposition to allow a Mit of the Crown to speak, one can rem ber an occasion only a few years ago when members of the Irish Nationalist Party were carried' out of the House by police. And if it be urged that at all events English members have never so lowered the House before, it may be pointed out that during Lord Salisbury's last Administration some prominent members of the Lower House actually' came to blows on ote occasion. It is, of course, serious thing to refuse a hearing to a Cabinet Minister and to drive the Speaker or his Deputy to the extreme remedy of abruptly ending the sitting; but one can conceive of circumstances in which such " course would be justifiable. The real reason that Monday's storm in the House is to be profoundly regretted is not so much that it has lowered the dignity of the House, as that it has enormonaly increased the bitterness of party feeling.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account