To the Editor of the Nonru-Cuima Dairy Ne Sir,—Your comments in this morning's issue under the heading of "Watchful Cruiser" are extremely interesting, particularly in that they presems the matter from a single and wholly partisan point of view. You state that "it seems extraordinary that the local German authorities should have allowed these people to start." You assume that in all probability the German Consulate very fool-idly thought the British were as-keep. If indeed these people were allowed to depart by the str. China solely because the German authorities thought the British were asloep the idea is indeed foolish a you suggest, extremely foolish.
But what ground is there for assuming such to have been the coset you not overlooked the fact that there are other phases of the matter worthy of consideration? 1s it not reasonable to assume that the fact that the © China flies the American flag played some pact in this unfortunate and regrettable incident? Is it likely that an American ship would receive so many German passengers on board without some definite ideas on the part of her owners or those responsible for her as to the rights, under the circumstances, of the nation whose flag the ship fiiest Was it a foolish idea, as you suggest, for this ship to leave Shanghai under the American flag with passe: of German nationality on board and expect immunity from what actually happened Is it foolish for American ship owners and citizens to expect England to observe the laws of neutrality in dealing with neutral and friendly nation?
The rules of International Law applying to the China are too clear to require any extended argument. They are the rules for whioh England herself has consistently contended and even been prepared to fight.
The case of the China is on all fours with that of the Trent. The British authority on International Law. In his discussion of the "Trent" case he states the British view of International Law as follows "Tt is incorrect to speak veyance of persons in the military or civil employment of a belligerent as if it were the same thing as the conveyance of contraband of war or as if the same rules were applicable to it. It isa different thing and the rules applicable to it are different. If a vessel is a0 hired bya belligerent that he has entire control over it to the extent of his special needs, the shin itself is confiscable as having acquired an enemy character and the persons on board become prisoners of war. If on the other hand belligerent persons, whatever their quality, go on board a neutral vessel as simple passengers to the place whither she is in any case bound, the ship remains neutral and covers the persons on board with the protection of her neutral character."
This is a principle of International Law for which England as contended from the days of he American civil war, and the "Trent" case down to the present time and from which she has never hitherto departed.
Tu the days of the American civil war and ever since that time England has been prepared to maintain this doctrine all hazards, Why then should German civilians hesitate to travel by American vessels may, as you suggest in your leader, redound to the prestige of the British in the eves of the Chin-ose that the British Navy is able to hold her enemies in check even so far from the scene of war as the Far East. But what impression does it create in the eyes of the Chinese that the American flag jated with impunity hin sight and hearing greatest port? Selfishness blinds the eyes of nations as regrettable, but it is indeed unfortunate that in congratulating your countrymen upon the impression you have made in the eyes of the Chinese you have entirely overlooked that same has been secured by a breach of the law of nations and an affront to the flag of ion of whose friendship in the time of trial you have had no cause to complain.
T am, ete, Shanghai, Feb. 21.
The misapprehensions contained in letter are dealt with in a leading article—Ed.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.