The Archive · 1925

JUDICIAL INQUIRY

Aug. 25.

So far back as July 16, more than seven weeks ago, as the result of the conference between Mr. Austen Chamberlain and the American, French, and Japan Ambassadors, it was announced that the Powers had decided to hold a public judicial inguii into the events of May 30. Some Jweeks of silence elapsed, inexplicable to simple minds, junable to realize why, in this lage of swift communications, remained to be settled but thatthe students and agitators has the full announcement might be|told them. Actually, we do not expected ip the near future.|think they believe it with any, Next after this came "the|very great warmth, but they anticipation of the "Manchester|have not been given anything which there is|else to believe.

Even. without reason to think was fairly near the truth, that the board Jof inquiry would be composed jof judges from Hongkong, the Philippines, Saigon, Tokyo, jand, of course, a Chinese judge. A fortnight ago there were rumours that the Commission might be announced at any moment. Then came the objection raised by the Peking Government to any judicial inquiry; ino announcement has ever been made; and there are further rumours that the Chinese refusal ito participate is held to constitute a practical has the addition of the Chinese judge, a Commission of Inquiry feomposed of judges from Hongkong, Saigon, the Philippines and Tokyo would constitute such a Bench as had never met before jand its prestige could not fail ito impress the Chinese people. No doubt the students and agitators would try to howl down its findings. But once it had pronounced judgment, what is Inow their chief lever with which {to stir on the business men and labourers of. China to boycotts jand, strikes would have been rakeh out of the agitators' hands. may not be correct. the moment of writing, the long-announcement may Jactually be upon the wires. But} somehow one does not think that it is, The Canton incident has intervened to distract diplomatic attention from an affair which {to a certain cast of mind already belongs to the limbo of things forgotten. And for this reason everyone in a position to make his voice heard should urge Jwith all the energy he can command, that, whether the Chinese take part in the inquiry or not, it must be held. It is easily understood why the Chinese do not desire it. Such an inquiry could hardly fail to expose the Bolshevist activities of Shanghai University, which fomented the strike in the Japanese mills and led up to the meute of May 30. It could hardly fail to expose amount of support which the Peking Government has given to the strike, It would certainly {throw uncomfortable light on the interest of certain members of ithe Chinese Chamber of Commerce in keeping the strike and boycott going. But all this is beside the point, not only regards foreigners, but also the Chinese people. It cannot be too often emphasized that the point lof supreme importance is to get the affair of May 30 out of the way. The strike is becoming feebler; merchants all over the country are beginning to realize that, in complying with the boyjeott, they are paying a heavy price for the student's "patriotism;" but there remains an under-current of bitterness which, until the affair of May 130 has been disposed of, continues to block all friendly' relations and may at any moment give rise new strikes and renewed dis-

There are two ways in which an official inquiry would help enormously to this end, whether for not a Chinese judge took part in it. In point of fact if the Powers firmly announced the formation of the Commission and the date on which it would begin work, the chances are that the Chinese would fall in with it. But whether they did or not, it ought to be held. In the first place, Shanghai ought to be cleared in the eyes of the world. Every post from England, America, and Continental countries brings us extracts from newspapers, by no means normally of "red" hue, containing grossly distorted accounts of what hapened on May 30 and of the supposed operation of municipal government in Shanghai. It is impossible for any newspaper to keep pace with these. Even a large, well organized propaganda, bureau, with nothing else to do, could hardly cope with so much malice and _misrepresentation, What is needed is an official The mistake into which gov-lornments and official representa. tives are in danger of fall mistake which with every day's delay runs more risk of obtaining general acceptance, is to regard everything connected with the present crisis as constituting single issue to be dealt with comprehensively in a single settlement. But there are really three issues, all entirely distinct, There is the issue in Canton, which stands apart both politi-ally and ethically from all the rest of China; there is the issue fof tariff revision, the Mixed Court, and other desiderata which the Chinese are striving might and main to tack on to ithe strike and boycott; but pre-eminently and most importantly alone, there is the affair of May 30. In the other issues we are only dealing with politicians and students. In respect of May 30 lwo are dealing with all classes lof Chinese who have any capacity for thinking about the affairs of their country. How-lever ill-informed and. illogical the thinking may be, that fact has to be faced. And until this, dispute can be adjusted, May 30 is as a piece of grit clogging the whole machinery of Chinese and foreign relationships.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account