The Archive · 1920

The Chinese Libel Action

Further Hearing at Mixed Court The Chinese libel action in which the Commercial Press, Ld., is suing the Chung Hua Book Ca., Ld., was resumed in the Mixed Court on Tuesday morning before the Assessor, Mr. Grant Jones, and Magistrate Yui. The claim as previously published in our columns, arises out of the alleged publication by the defendants of a work in which it was stated that the plaintiff firm was in reality a "Sino-Japanese concern."

Mr. G. H. Wright and Mr. Alex. Ting appeared for the plaintiffs and Mr. H, D. Rodger for the defendants.

Mr. Newman then applied for an adjournment of the hearing so that Mr. Godfrey who had been associated with Mr. Rodger, who was then in the hospital, might continue in the defence. Mr. Wright objected on the ground that Mr. Godfrey was brought into the case only at the last hearing, and that Mr. Rodger who had the control of the case from the beginning might continue.

The Assessor—It seems from Mr. Godfrey's letter to Mr. Rodger that this application is really not, that of Mr. Godfrey personally but that of the defendants. If it were Mr. Godfrey's we might grant it. But as it is that of the defendants, who have had ample opportunity of making arrangements beforehand but have failed to do so, we must have the case proceeded with.

Mr, Chang Yuen-chi, Manager of the Commercial Press, Ld., was again called in to the box.

According to his evidence editorials were published in local papers acd also in Hankow papers showing how seriously the matter was regarded by the public. Some people who used to buy the firm's books have ceased to do so whilst others who have bought them have returned them. They had suffered a good deal of loss in their business. By means of proportion they did less business during July, August and September, by $240,000—that is for all our branches. The amount of profit on: this turnover should be 30 per cent. ie., about $70,009. The important periods im our business are January and February and August, ie. for Shanghai, in_ the provinces one month later. These periods are when the schools are open, they have only two terms.

'A chit book wherein a notice of meeting regarding the redemption of Japanese capital was sent to the manager of defendant Company. The book was produced as also the notice of meeting to be held on

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account