The Archive · 1925

Freedom and Fetters

4. Your suggestion that I do not know what the word autonomy means is very interesting. For you say that no tonomous, strictly speaking. view point of your administration then China is indeed lost at the Tarif Conference. For every sovereign state is autonomous. Autonomy means the right of a Rate to self-government. It means independence. Naturally indepenident states may be in agreement or disagreement. They may have reciprocal relations. They may form Sffensive and defensive alliances. 'They send ambassadors and ministers to each other and sign' and abrogate treaties. Te is tation may not do thes freely that it has lost its autonomy. Te is when nation han to the dictates of others, that it la without autonomy." Can you Imagine yourself writing to. the President of the "United States fand ordering him to reduce the silke duty to 74 per cent. Can you Imagine yourself writing to. the King. of England and dictating him that he should reduce the duly on tea, You cannot, 'The reason that those countries have' tariff autonomy. No one can tell them what to do. When the United Btates wanted a reciprocity. treaty vith, Canada, Canada rejected the HYreaty. That is the right of an autonomous nation. 'The United States excluded wine which, in {eftect, hurt French trade although reduced the "American Custom revenue, but France could not say' word. it is because the" United States enjoy tariff autonomy.

I go into these details so that you will understand. We do not njoy autonomy because we signed wway our rights by treaty. We are not ina position to abrogate change that without the consent of the Powers because ave wasted Gur heritage and allowed—misgovernment and. usurpation to destroy our strength. We must con-[tinue to bea country, "in name independent, but actually. dependent upon those Powers which have the treaty right to dictate to us. If then you continue to misunderstand the real significance of our ery for it Autonomy, you altogether misunderstand what the" Chines people want. They know that the Powers will not agree to autonomy until we have unity and a competent Government. You know that neither is possible except through the subordination of the military to the civil authority, except through constitutional methods and a democratic Government. No one will submit to you even as Chief Executive, for. they will ask you how did you become Chief, Executive, by what right, by what law? Therefore, when we say we int Tariff Alitonomy we really {demand that conditions shall created in China which will make it no longer possible for the Powers to withald from us what we originally should never have given up to them.

You emphasize the words, "rec proval." With whom has China reciprocal tariff? "Can China make reciprocal tariff with one nation thout all of them enjoying the privileges under the Favoured Nation Clause? I suggest that you consult the Ministry concerned on the subject.

Why I Refused Office 5. You say that I am an armchair critic of the Government and that I do nothing for the country.:|Perhaps you are right, but I can only allow our people to judge as between, us on, that account." You say that you held open the post Jof Minister of Foreign Affairs for me bat that I would not come up to Peking. Has not your settlement of the Gold Prane question and similar acts justified my remaining in retirement? For had T come up to Peking, we would have quarrelled immediately over such matters, for I would never, have {allowed the Waichiaopu to be used

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account