The Archive · 1905

ASIATIC IMMIGRATION

6th October.

"British Columbia seems determined to make a stand against the immigration of Japanese; though with' a population "probably -not exceeding one poison to every "two square miles of area her action cannot claim to be justified: by any' surplus of population. But asin the United States, in Australia, and elsewhere the objection comes from the working classes, who fear to be ousted from their occtipations or to have the standard scales of wages reduced by the competition of cheap Asiatic labour. This objection is about well justified as that which was raised not so very long back, as time goes, in history against the introduction of machinery. Che workmen then rose in revolt because as they then alleged, the bread was being taken out of their mouths, and events have as completely shown the ultimate fallacy of their conduct in the one case as they will dome to do in the other. Not, however, that there was not real cause for complaint when the machine usurped the place of the handworker, He did lose by the change even it his ch: ldren gained by it, and the somewhat unctuous platitudes of the political economists of the time were not of much avail to the man who was turned out of one occupation and had neither time. to learn another, nor ability to do so were he given the opportunity. The machine lessened cost of production and so lessened prices, while at the same time it did not ultimately lessen in any corresponding measure the value of human effort in those directions in which the machine was of no avail, and the net result is that the worker is better off to-day than he wes before the introduction of machine labour—his nominal wages are higher, and their actual purchasing power is on the average greater. inhere is less to be said against the introduction of Asiatic labour than was to be said against machinery. In some places the Asiatic does not compete. with the white man at all. This is so regarding outdoor, or indeed any manual, Ixbour in tropical or sub-tropical countries, yet Asiatic Jabour is now excluded from Queensland, and in North Queensland at any rate the white man: is of very little avail in agriculture. In this case we have industry being rained by the sheer want of common sense of the Australian labour party," which is all powerful in the legislature.

In British Columbia indeed there is no reason why' the white man should not do manual labour, but with an enormous area and a very sparse population"the development of the country isnot to be hoped for save by the aid of: Asiatics, for Earopenn immigration, flooding: as it is into Canada at the present time, is nevertheless absorbed long before it reaches the Pacific coast. It is the monopolist who takes this stand in British Columbia, for labour being searce endeavours to monopolise itself, and may do so successfully for some time in a new country of great natural resources where capital is constantly seeking investment. But 'a nemesis would be bound to come, for capital will not continue (o' enter country where there is not labour available at a moilerate- price, and labour, however - scarce, can, have demand for it ceases. There are little power once the capitalistic

instances in which this labour monopoly is useful to.combat those mono-politic capitalistic enterprises known as trusts, which depend for.their power not only on the resources at their disposal but on the: presence of an abundant labour supply, forced to seek employment so eagerly as to be bound to comply with unreasonable behests of the employer. On this ground there is some justification for the exclusion policy pursued in the United States, for any great increase in the available. labour supply of that country would enormously strengthen the trus's and.correspondingly weaken: the: hands of labour which, with little or no capital at its disposal, cannot afford to wait, and must depend for its strength on complete union, rendered. impossible by the invasion of large and alien hordes of labour, But Canada is not at the mercy of a plutocracy and is not likely to become so, It' seems on the face of it absurd that the legislature of British Columbia, which represents the electors among a white population not exceeding in all, in-clading women and children, one-fiftieth part "of the population of London should have the presumption to attempt to prevent the development of a country over four hundred thousand square miles in area. Such policy nob only checks internal development but' also reduces the demand: of British Columbia for' the products 6f other: parts of Canada: and of other countries, and the limitation of possible. exports limits the supply of them available for consumers abroad- and limits the' opportunity and the' inclination of capital to berake itself td a country where the labour supply is artificialip. Kept, below. the real effective lemand, It is-unlikéely: that British Columbia will be allowed to persist in the course she is following.. It is absurd that she should, quite apart from the considerations of international policy introduced by the relationships that have, sprang up.between Great Britain and Japan.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account