The Archive · 1910

The Chinese Theory of Justice

Arrmxtion has recently been called to several incidents, which illustrate in a remarkable degree the wide variance between the Chinese and European notions of justice and the relative attitude of the people of this country and foreigners towards cruelty. In the notorious case of Ng Ab-dau we had: the, most outrageous cruelty exercised by 8 magistrate upon an unlucky prisoner, in a manner that could not fail to arouse the strongest indignation of every European. The matter was taken up by the authorities of the foreign settlement and the man was rescued by them out of the hands of one of his own' officials. Not a sound of protest, however, has been raised among the Chinese, and, as far as we are aware, the only corollary to the episode has been the sentence of three black marks against the name of the magistrate for having surrendered the prisoner to foreign jurisdiction. Yet the treatment meted out to Ng Ab-dau was essentially barbarous, and it occurs ata time when there is a strong national movement for reform with the object. of enabling China to take 2 higher position in the family of nations. Again, according to a Chitiesp newspaper, several hundred lashes on the bare back were recently inflicted upon a woman found dressed as a man and she was subsequently ordered to be-strangled. The newspaper publishing this report offers no comment and no one suggests that the penalty is excessive. On. the other hand s Chinese newspaper is suspended by order of the Mixed Court and at once ther is a loud outcry. The irregularities that were made the subject of protest in the) latter.case were identical with those that prefaced the cruelty practised upon Ng Ab-dau; but whereas in the suspension of the "Min Hsu Pao" there was an encroachment upon vested interests, when Ng Ab-dau was nearly beaten to death, unjustly and without trial, the personal feelings of one man lone were affected. Thus the Chinese senae of justice is, offended when a business firm is suspended. without

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account